Who would you rather have? Why? If you were Calgary would you trade Phaneuf for Malkin straight up? If you were Pittsburgh would you trade Malkin for Phaneuf straight up? I was thinking about this tonight and couldn't decide between the two. Its really hard to get a stud dman like Phaneuf but Malkin's potential continues to rise which is hard to imagine (I wish he was in Pittsburgh this year). If i'm Calgary I don't think I trade Phaneuf straight up, but you never know. If i'm Pittsburgh it would be hard to trade Malkin but I think I might do it because they've already got a #1 Centre in Crosby, a future #1 goalie in Fleury, now they need a #1 dman and I think Phaneuf could be that for them in a year or two. Thoughts everyone?