Keeper potential: McAvoy or Provorov

[AvalancheSpeedsters]

yahoo standard h2h categories (hits, blocks pims , goals assists power play points , +\- etc)and we get three keepers for the following year . I have McAvoy and Provorov but can’t decide which one would be the best value going forward . I have Rantanen and Mack as my first two keepers . Potentially Dubois but I love those two D .

It seems McAvoy would produce a bit more but Provorov is no slouch either . Provorov would cost me a 11th round pick to keep while McAvoy would cost me a 9th rounder . Thoughts ?

Click to read more...

 

[Derg12]

I picked up McAvoy weeks ago and won't be dropping him at all unless I get an offer that highly over pays. The only way I might trade him out depends on how many keepers our league decides on this season since it's our first year with keepers. I have Barzal, Point, McAvoy, Keller, and Heinen.... and if Wild Bill Karlsson continues his crazy ride, I might have to throw him in the mix as well.

I've got decisions to make because I'm certain I won't be able to keep them all but McAvoy is the only Dman in my list which I have to give special consideration.

 

[AdamParrot]

Provorov. Every day.

 

[Not Jared Cowen]

McAvoy has less competition for prime offensive opportunities. Both are their teams #1s going forward but I could see Provo being used similarly to how Pietro was used in St. Louis prior to Shattenkirk leaving. Philly is loaded with good defensive prospects and one of the premier powerplay QBs in the league in Ghostbear.

 

[MasterMatt25]

I'd prefer McAvoy. Gets more ice-time and less competition for offensive opportunities

 

[kk]

Don't think you can lose either way. Clearer path for McAvoy right now for production however.

 

[rangerssharks414]

Provorov because of the two round difference, but you can't really go wrong

 

[tmg]

I'd prefer McAvoy. Gets more ice-time

Might wanna check the stats on that one. Provorov is 15th in the league in average time on ice. McAvoy is T-39th.

McAvoy likely outproduces offensively, they’re near even in hits, but Provorov is near double McAvoy in blocked shots. Given that it costs the op a higher pick to keep McAvoy, I’d hold Provorov. But it is damned close.

 

[MasterMatt25]

Might wanna check the stats on that one. Provorov is 15th in the league in average time on ice. McAvoy is T-39th.

McAvoy likely outproduces offensively, they’re near even in hits, but Provorov is near double McAvoy in blocked shots. Given that it costs the op a higher pick to keep McAvoy, I’d hold Provorov. But it is damned close.

I stand corrected

 

[adamkesher]

Provorov for sure.

 

[BinCookin]

Here is the analysis using the data sheets I am developing.

I have extrapolated both players stats to 51 GP for this year.
they rank near equal on my sheet (PIMS and +/- for McAvoy) (SOG and BLKS for Provorov) are the big keys.
I find +/- to be the more team based stat. So i would choose Provorov. But the choice is very close.

 

[Yarbles02]

I’d take Mcavoy given that he will likely have less competition for the prime opportunities. Mcavoys upside in keepers is huge!

 

[Club]

Provorov for myself

 

[shello]

I'd do McAvoy