John Carlson or Roman Josi

[Sempiternal]

Who would you keep for another few seasons? Carlson or Josi

Let's assume Carlson stays in Washington.

Carlson's season has been amazing, but contract year and significantly better than past seasons. He is the undisputed #1 dman on his team and on a potent PP.

Josi's season has been less flashy, but he's consistently very good. He is not the clear #1 dman on his team. Had a few injuries so his point total is misleading. Had a 5 point game this season.

Before this season I'd say Josi without a doubt but now its up for debate.

Points only league. Who would you keep?

Click to read more...

 

[RonTextall]

Josi

 

[MasterMatt25]

Josi

 

[Boris Le Tigre]

Also Josi...

 

[rangerssharks414]

Another vote for Josi...

 

[Sempiternal]

lol I traded both and now have Victor Hedman.

 

[lakai17]

Josi and I'm rather high on Carlson

 

[Spirit of 67]

Josi all the way.
With all due respect to Carlson.

 

[xgallantx]

Hmmmm, can't go wrong either way, but I might lean Carlson on this one. Josi has more trade appeal if you still have time to trade him

I'm also interested as I have both Carlson and Klingberg and am only going to keep one of them. I'm leaning Klingberg and I looking to make a deal involving Carlson - we open off-season trading for the entirity of the Stanley Cup Finals, wether it's a four game sweep or a seven gamer.

 

[MasterMatt25]

lol I traded both and now have Victor Hedman.

Ok