When we decided to go with playoffs, this is the type of matchup I dreamed of. Buffalo/Hamilton was THE series of the preliminary round. This will be THE matchup of the second round. There are some other strong matchups (Montreal/Boston comes to mind) but I think this is the one to sit down and watch and enjoy great playoff-style hockey. I've been looking forward to this one since before the start of the first round.
If Murphy2 is going to win, he's going to need great goaltending. I think even VanI would admit there's an edge here. Sawchuk is No. 1 on some lists, and in the top five on every knowledgeable fans' list. Hainsworth is top 10 on some lists. I'm a huge Mike Vernon fan, but I'll definitely take eight-time all-star Brimsek. (Only two all-star selections came when the best were overseas). You hope that the No. 3's won't be a factor.
Defence is really tough to call, not only from the blue-line perspective, but from the overall team perspective. Both teams have a lot of strong defensive forwards. Looking at the blue lines, I like Edmonton's No. 1 a little more than Burnaby's (I think Pilote is the most underrated all-time great in the history of the game). Bouchard gives Pilote a strong defensive conscience, enabling Pilote to concentrate of his offensive duties. The other two pairings are good offence-defence tandems, too. Burnaby will be hard-pressed to get many odd-man rushes, as Edmonton has some of the finest two-way forwards in the draft. Gainey and Provost would be my ideal third line LW and RW, respectively.
I like VanI's top four a lot. MacInnis and Suchy are big bombers from the point. MacInnis doesn't need a defensive conscience, but he has a reliable two-way force in Vasiliev. Mike Ramsey will certainly give Suchy the freedom to roam. Don't really know much about the other two defencemen, but I do like Sogulobov, but I couldn't pass up the chance to take the physical swashbuckler Barilko. (Hey, four Cups in five years). There's a strong two-way presence on the bottom three lines, although for some reason, I don't think Turgeon fits in well with Propp and Lehtinen at all. Hmmm, super soft one-dimensional underachiever centre, teamed with one of the best defensive RWs of all-time, and the top scoring LW in playoff history who was a strong presence in the defensive zone and in the corners.
Murphy2, I will definitely take you to task with your comment that Otto is overrated. If anything, he's underrated. Scouts across the world are still looking for the next Joel Otto: a big, strong centre who dominates physically AND defensively, is a force in the faceoff circle, and can get you 50 points per season. We've seen reasonable facsimilies (Primeau, Holik at various points in their careers) but nobody who has come into the league and come close to what Otto could do. Prototypes are never overrated.
VanI gets a definite nod on offence. He has that proven game-breaker element that Murphy2 doesn't have. We know what Gretzky and Kurri can do offensively. Kamensky is potent. They lack that true game breaker (a guy who can go for two goals and two assists when Gretzky and Kurri are held off the scoresheet) but they have a lot of solid, reliable scorers who should be good for around a point-per-game, guys like Shanahan, Roenick, Larmer, Propp. If his head's on straight, Turgeon be the No. 3 scorer on the team. And they have MacInnis, Vasiliev and Suchy on the point.
The closest things to a proven game-breaker in Edmonton are Sittler and Pitre. That's bad news. But what they do have is a lot of players who live for this time of year, especially Kennedy and Anderson. He reunited Sittler and MacDonald, and call me crazy, but I think Brian Sutter (he of multiple 40-goal/250-PIM seasons) might fit better on that line than Tiger Williams.
The big matchup is Gainey-Sutter-Provost vs. Kamensky-Gretzky-Kurri. Expect to see Gainey's line, and likely Bouchard, to be matched up against Gretzky's line in the three games in Burnaby. This is the best bet in the draft to contain Gretzky's line. The one caveat for Burnaby is this: the Mountaineers will want to get Gretzky away from that match-up, but the other three lines are tough to play against as well. There isn't a defensively weak line in the line-up.
Burnaby has a definite edge in coaching. Then again, Burnaby will have a definite coaching edge against every team remaining, except for Moscow, and that wouldn't happen until the final.
This is going to be an awesome series. It'll go the distance.