Jake Gardiner Vs Tj Brodie Vs Nick Leddy

[McDavidCrushedLarkin]

Brodie
Leddy



Gardiner

 

[Kase]

Thought Brodie would bounce back and have a better season compared to last season. I guess that hasn't happened, at least yet.

Somehow I always forget that Leddy even exists...I have underrated him big time. Voted Leddy this time, but I think that he and Brodie are going to be neck to neck when the season ends.

 

[sebsisles]

Do people really think Gardiner is better than Leddy?

 

[Hugh Mungus]

brodie
leddy
.
.
.

 

[Hugh Mungus]

Do people really think Gardiner is better than Leddy?

2 people even think hes better than brodie

 

[WesMcCauley]

Leddy
Brodie
Gardiner

 

[NarcoPolo]

Do people really think Gardiner is better than Leddy?

He was as good as him last year, probably even better. They're close imo

 

[McDavidCrushedLarkin]

Do people really think Gardiner is better than Leddy?

There's people out there I'm sure that think Gardiner > Karlsson

 

[boredmale]

Don't look now but I believe Leddy is 3rd in defenseman scoring(after starting the season with 2 assists in his first 9 games). If you look at Leddy's stats, he seems to be getting better and better every season(save his 2nd season in the league)

 

[GongShowWilly]

still Brodie

 

[Addison Rae]

Canucks fan saying Brodie, stop overvaluing small sample sizes.

 

[TychoFan]

Would Isles fans say Leddy is their best defenseman?

 

[boredmale]

Would Isles fans say Leddy is their best defenseman?

No doubt about it

 

[The Winter Soldier]

Leddy with 2 assists and another great game. Best kept secret in the game. Now has 18 pts in 21 games.

 

[biturbo19]

I'd take Leddy. Runner up is TJ Brodie. But i feel like there's a sort of weird perception overall that Leddy is somehow "older" and more likely to decline sooner. Probably because of when they hit the NHL, respectively. Even though that's clearly not the case.

For me, Leddy is a guy who can anchor a Top-4 D pairing, arguably even a pretty decent top-pairing...whereas Brodie tends to be a guy who needs a bit of babysitting if he's going to face tough matchups.

They're both very good defencemen though. And i wouldn't hesitate for an instant to take either of them over Gardiner.

 

[Lays]

Rangers fan here saying
Leddy
Brodie

Gardiner

Leddy is one of the most underrated dmen in the game while Brodie’s one of the most overrated. Both are good 2D’s though. Gardiner is a high end 3D

 

[Dion TheFluff]

1 of these things is not like the others

 

[djpatm]

Honestly, TJ Brodie has been hot garbage in his own end since Gulutzan took over as coach.

 

[McFlyingV]

I would have taken Brodie 2 years ago quite easily, but I just really can't get a grasp on him these days. At first I thought it was just a bad stretch last year that he'd recover from, but he hasn't been anywhere near his 2015-16 form in over 100 games now. Maybe he'll figure it out and get back to that, but I really don't know.

Because of that I'm going with Leddy.

 

[Buds17]

1. Leddy
2. Brodie
3. Gardiner

 

[Beautvillier]

Would Isles fans say Leddy is their best defenseman?

yeah

 

[flamesforcup]

I would have taken Brodie 2 years ago quite easily, but I just really can't get a grasp on him these days. At first I thought it was just a bad stretch last year that he'd recover from, but he hasn't been anywhere near his 2015-16 form in over 100 games now. Maybe he'll figure it out and get back to that, but I really don't know.

Because of that I'm going with Leddy.

Yup he has looked off defensively this year though he has been pretty good offensively. Hopefully he can pick it up

 

[stl76]

I didn’t realize Leddy was this underrated...

 

[The Winter Soldier]

I can't believe Leddy has only 34% of the vote here. This to me suggests not enough people have been watching Isles games this year.

 

[Volica]

You mean Jake the Gardener?

It's like the Snake, but much, much lamer.