Voted neither. One great, but overrated playoff run. Two great regular seasons, in between which he was put on waivers and went unclaimed. The rest of the league apparently realized his great numbers were largely a product of the system. One of the most unlikely underdog/out of nowhere stories you'll ever see, so I suppose he has the "Fame" aspect covered for that reason. I guess it depends on one's definition of "Hall of Very Good". In my own mind I'd say maybe the best 20 goaltenders not in the actual HOF are who I think of for this. Thomas doesn't make that cut for me.