PurpleShamrock said:
I've heard that platitude as well; people have also said that about Babe Ruth. Personally, I'm with Puddy on this one: Given Orr's raw talent, I frankly see no reason to believe that he wouldn't have dominated today's game, given that he would have benefitted from the same advances in training, nutrition and medicine that today's players enjoy. Of course, when everything is said and done, the hypothesis is speculative and moot, because obviously there's no way it can be either proven or disproven.
Bobby Orr would dominate the game today if he had the same training, nutrition and such that he did have. He wouldn't need modern training habits to be dominant. You could slide him into a time machine at age 22 and move him to today and he is by far the best defenceman in the NHL.
This is my argument.....in an attempt to "prove" that Orr would be dominant in today's NHL. Great players remain great players until the end of their careers or until they are in their late 30's or 40. I am talking truly great players. Denis Potvin was a top defenceman as a rookie and the season he retired. Bourque was a first team All-Star as a rookie in 1980 and in his final year 2001. Chelios was a first team ALL Star in 2002 at age 40. Stevens was dominant as a rookie and in his last season. Gordie Howe was dominant in the late 1940's and was still in the top 3 in scoring in 1969 when he was past 40 years old. Great players remain great players. They transend era's. Howe started his career in 1945/46 an NHL that played 60 games. The top goalie was Bill Durnan. Max Bentley was the leading scorer, Milt Schmidt, Turn Broda, Syl Apps were still playing and still top players. In 1969 he was the third person to get 100 points. In 1970 he was a first team All-Star. In 1971 his last season before his first retirement he was still a top player and there were now 14 teams. Players like Gilbert Perrault, Bobby Clarke, Phil Esposito, Bobby Orr a complete generation of stars were some of the great players of the time. Ken Dryden, Tony Esposito, Bernie Parent were some of the top goalies.
Howe played through as a true top player in the league (Not Counting his WHA and 79/80 NHL return) eras where the top goalies were Durnan, Broda, Brimsek. And when Sawchuk, Hall, Plante and Parent, Dryden, Esposito. And then if you count 79-80. Liut, Billy Smith.
Orr most certainly could play well in the current era. If not for his knee injuries he may well have played until 1985 or even 1990. Bourque played against Gordie Howe, Bobby Hull, Phil Esposito, Perrault, Tony Esposito, Trottier, Sittler, Shutt. And he also played against Havlat, Richards, Visnovsky, Elias, Brodeur, Hossa.
People who think that this era is so much different than other eras or that players of the recent past could not dominate this era don't understand that Great Players dominate any era. This is proven as the best players dominate cross hockey eras.
Howe (reportedly) opened beer bottles with his teeth on train rides after games between Detroit and Montreal. That kind of training allowed him to play 32 years of professional hockey. Gretzky could (reportedly) not even bench press his weight even one time early in his career when he was the top scorer in the NHL. He played 20 seasons and was second team All-Star his second last season.
One last example. Henri Richard won the Stanley cup in 1955-56 with Rocket Richard, Beliveau, Harvey, Olmstead, Geoffrion, Plante. He won in 72/73 with Lafleur, Dryden, Lemaire, Shutt, Robinson, Serge Savard, Lapointe, Cournoyer. He was an effective and important player on both Cup teams.