MXD
Original #4
- Oct 27, 2005
- 50,812
- 16,549
Here are the results for Round 3 of the History of Hall Hall of Fame -- Early Era group.
There were 27 voters (108 votes) submitted this time around. Participation level was quite stable, and there was some pretty interesting discussions as well. The discussions can be read here
http://hfboards.com/showthread.php?p=30777191
There was some serious streamlining in the voting this round, leading to 3 new inductees (and one that missed by the smallest possible margin)
The History of Hockey Hall of Fame is please to welcome...
A pioneer, high-principled gentleman, and an extremely skilled pucked controler; A cornerstone of the first dynasty of the NHL who also found success with weaker teams; and a terrific mix of toughness, offensive prowess, defensive effeciency and nutcase-ism.
- Rover/F Russel Dubbie Bowie
- G Clint Benedict
- D Sprague Cleghorn
Reflexions?
- Malone missed by a vote, and was in for a while.
- We lost some voters, which might explain why some guys lost votes (Dan Bain, amongst others).
- The next round might give some really interesting discussions, and I wouldn't be surprised to see guys who didn't get a vote this round get quite a few next round. It's safe to say that this round is quite a serious turning point.
There were 27 voters (108 votes) submitted this time around. Participation level was quite stable, and there was some pretty interesting discussions as well. The discussions can be read here
http://hfboards.com/showthread.php?p=30777191
There was some serious streamlining in the voting this round, leading to 3 new inductees (and one that missed by the smallest possible margin)
The History of Hockey Hall of Fame is please to welcome...
A pioneer, high-principled gentleman, and an extremely skilled pucked controler; A cornerstone of the first dynasty of the NHL who also found success with weaker teams; and a terrific mix of toughness, offensive prowess, defensive effeciency and nutcase-ism.
- Rover/F Russel Dubbie Bowie
- G Clint Benedict
- D Sprague Cleghorn
History of Hockey Hall of Fame -- Round 3
|
Player
|
Votes
|
% of votes
|
1| Russel "Dubbie" Bowie |24|88.89%
2| Clint Benedict |24|88.89%
3| Sprague Cleghorn |23|85.19%
4| Joe Malone |21|77.78%
5| Dan Bain |6|22.22%
6| Harvey Pulford |2|7.41%
7| Cy Denneny |2|7.41%
8| Frank McGee |2|7.41%
9| Hobey Baker |2|7.41%
10| Georges Vezina |1|3.70%
11| Lester Patrick |1|3.70%
1| Russel "Dubbie" Bowie |24|88.89%
2| Clint Benedict |24|88.89%
3| Sprague Cleghorn |23|85.19%
4| Joe Malone |21|77.78%
5| Dan Bain |6|22.22%
6| Harvey Pulford |2|7.41%
7| Cy Denneny |2|7.41%
8| Frank McGee |2|7.41%
9| Hobey Baker |2|7.41%
10| Georges Vezina |1|3.70%
11| Lester Patrick |1|3.70%
Reflexions?
- Malone missed by a vote, and was in for a while.
- We lost some voters, which might explain why some guys lost votes (Dan Bain, amongst others).
- The next round might give some really interesting discussions, and I wouldn't be surprised to see guys who didn't get a vote this round get quite a few next round. It's safe to say that this round is quite a serious turning point.