HOH Top 60 Wingers List & Voting Record - tarheelhockey

[TheDevilMadeMe]

Round 1 List
HOH Top 60 Wingers List & Voting Record - tarheelhockey - HFBoards

Players from our final top 60 not ranked in this top 60
Sweeney Schriner at 62
Roy Conacher at 63
Vladimir Martinec at 67
Helmuts Balderis at 69
Rick Middleton at 73
Marian Hossa at 76
Daniel Alfredsson at 80
Patrik Elias (not ranked)
Alexander Yakushev (not ranked)
Paul Thompson (not ranked)
Theo Fleury (not ranked)

Players unique to this list
Lorne Carr
Camille Henry
Herb Cain
Jiri Lala
Ken Hodge

Players ranked highest overall on this list
Bobby Hull (tied with 18 others)
Guy Lafleur (tied with 2 others)
Ted Lindsay (tied with 1 other)
Alexander Ovechkin (tied with 4 others)
Charlie Conacher (tied with 2 others)
Busher Jackson (tied with 1 other)
Bryan Hextall
Rod GIlbert
Bill Mosienko
Woody Dumart
Lynn Patrick

Players ranked 2nd highest on this list
Jaromir Jagr (tied with 4 others)
Doug Bentley (tied with 2 others)
Luc Robitaille
Bert Olmstead
Cecil Dillon
Bill Barber (tied with 1 other)
Sid Smith
Jiri Holik
Lanny McDonald

Players ranked lowest overall on this list
Maurice Richard
Valeri Kharlamov
Boris Mikhailov
Pavel Bure
Vladimir Martinec
Daniel Alfredsson

Players ranked 2nd lowest on this list
Aurele Joliat (tied with 1 other)
Marian Hossa

Round 2 Voting

Higher than anyone else

Vote 5 - Iginla in 1st
Vote 9 - R Conacher in 2nd
Vote 12 - Balderis in 2nd

Lower than anyone else

NONE

Click to read more...

 

[MXD]

Ah ah ! So it was Lafleur ahead of Richard. Good to see you reversed them

 

[tarheelhockey]

Yeah, for whatever reason I had Lafleur really high on the initial list and then dropped him much further back in the round 2 voting.

 

[TheDevilMadeMe]

Random trivia - tarheel is the only one who had Jagr 3rd in Round 2. Most voters had him either 2nd or 4th (with a few lower).

 

[VMBM]

Jiri Holik 13 places above Vladimir Martinec? Riight. Holik may have been the more responsible two-way player, but then when you compare their stats and accolades... it's a no contest.

However, it is somehow refreshing to see Kurri above Selänne (and not too far from Bossy), and Jiri Lala is a nice surprise there.

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

Jiri Holik 13 places above Vladimir Martinec? Riight. Holik may have been the more responsible two-way player, but then when you compare their stats and accolades... it's a no contest.

However, it is somehow refreshing to see Kurri above Selänne (and not too far from Bossy), and Jiri Lala is a nice surprise there.

Agreed. Though I didn't have either as high as this.

Is Reg Noble the Pat Lafontaine of wingers?

Glad to see Sid Smith get some props.

 

[Canadiens1958]

Bob Gainey and Craig Ramsey

The following Lorne Carr,Camille Henry, Herb Cain,Ken Hodge ahead of Bob Gainey and Craig Ramsey.

 

[seventieslord]

Agreed. Though I didn't have either as high as this.

Is Reg Noble the Pat Lafontaine of wingers?

Glad to see Sid Smith get some props.

I don't get it.

The following Lorne Carr,Camille Henry, Herb Cain,Ken Hodge ahead of Bob Gainey and Craig Ramsey.

Yeah, that's kinda hard to defend. I wonder if tarheel still thinks that or if this project has led to him rethinking that (despite us only talking about one of these players).

 

[TheDevilMadeMe]

You seem to have had a major change in how you viewed Iginla, Hull, St Louis and Kurri in comparison to each other between Votes 5 and 6. Especially Iginla vs Kurri.

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

I don't get it.



Yeah, that's kinda hard to defend. I wonder if tarheel still thinks that or if this project has led to him rethinking that (despite us only talking about one of these players).

Most voters had him around 60th. Like Lafontaine in the center's voting.