HOH Top 60 Defensemen List & Voting Record - intylerwetrust

[overpass]

intylerwetrust

Rank | Player
1 | Bobby Orr
2 | Doug Harvey
3 | Eddie Shore
4 | Ray Bourque
5 | Nicklas Lidstrom
6 | Denis Potvin
7 | Red Kelly
8 | Larry Robinson
9 | Chris Chelios
10 | Paul Coffey
11 | Brad Park
12 | Slava Fetisov
13 | Tim Horton
14 | Al MacInnis
15 | Dit Clapper
16 | Pierre Pilote
17 | Scott Stevens
18 | King Clancy
19 | Chris Pronger
20 | Earl Seibert
21 | Brian Leetch
22 | Scott Niedermayer
23 | Sprague Cleghorn
24 | Bill Gadsby
25 | Borje Salming
26 | Rod Langway
27 | Valeri Vasiliev
28 | Serge Savard
29 | Guy Lapointe
30 | Bill Quackenbush
31 | Alexander Ragulin
32 | Jack Stewart
33 | Butch Bouchard
34 | Rob Blake
35 | Ken Reardon
36 | Mark Howe
37 | Larry Murphy
38 | Jacques Laperriere
39 | Marcel Pronovost
40 | Carl Brewer
41 | Art Coulter
42 | Tom Johnson
43 | Zdeno Chara
44 | Babe Siebert
45 | Ebbie Goodfellow
46 | Vitaly Davydov
47 | Lionel Conacher
48 | Ching Johnson
49 | Sergei Zubov
50 | Harry Howell
51 | Phil Housley
52 | Pat Stapleton
53 | Fern Flaman
54 | Viktor Kuzkin
55 | Sergei Gonchar
56 | Nikolai Sologubov
57 | Adam Foote
58 | Alexei Kasatonov
59 | Babe Pratt
60 | Allan Stanley
61 | Harry Cameron
62 | Doug Wilson
63 | Sylvio Mantha
64 | J.C. Tremblay
65 | Jan Suchy
66 | Leo Reise
67 | Jack Marshall
68 | Glen Harmon
69 | Lester Patrick
70 | Derian Hatcher
71 | Kevin Lowe
72 | Brad McCrimmon
73 | Keith Magnusson
74 | Bert Corbeau
75 | Anders Eldebrink
76 | Craig Ludwig
77 | Jean-Guy Talbot
78 | Gary Suter
79 | Lennart Svedberg
80 | Jiri Bubla

Players from the Top 60 not to appear on this list
Eddie Gerard
Hod Stuart
Moose Johnson
George Boucher
Harvey Pulford
Frantisek Pospisil

Players ranked highest overall on this list
Art Coulter (41)
Vitaly Davydov (46)
Viktor Kuzkin (54)

Players ranked lowest overall on this lst
J.C. Tremblay (64)

Players unique to this list
Leo Reise (66)
Jack Marshall (67)
Glen Harmon (68)
Kevin Lowe (71)
Keith Magnusson (73)
Anders Eldebrink (75)
Craig Ludwig (76)

Round | Rank 1 | Rank 2 | Rank 3 | Rank 4 | Rank 5 | Rank 6 | Rank 7 | Rank 8 | Rank 9 | Rank 10
Vote 1|Orr|Harvey|Shore|Bourque|Lidstrom|Potvin|Kelly|Robinson|Chelios| Fetisov
Vote 2|Denis Potvin|Leonard "Red" Kelly|Larry Robinson|Chris Chelios|Paul Coffey|Brad Park|Al MacInnis|Viacheslav Fetisov|King Clancy|Pierre Pilote
Vote 3|Paul Coffey|Brad Park|Tim Horton|Al MacInnis|Pierre Pilote|Earl Seibert|Francis "King" Clancy|Scott Stevens|Sprague Cleghorn|Brian Leetch
Vote 4|Al MacInnis|Tim Horton|Dit Clapper|Earl Seibert|Scott Stevens|Chris Pronger|Bill Gadsby|Brian Leetch|Borje Salming|Valeri Vasiliev
Vote 5|Dit Clapper|Brian Leetch|Rod Langway|Bill Gadsby|Borje Salming|Scott Niedermayer|Bill Quackenbush|Jack Stewart|Valeri Vasiliev|Mark Howe
Vote 6|Rod Langway|Scott Niedermayer|Bill Quackenbush|Emile "Butch" Bouchard|Jack Stewart|Mark Howe|Serge Savard|Guy Lapointe|Eddie Gerard|J.C. Tremblay
Vote 7|Scott Niedermayer|Emile "Butch" Bouchard|Jack Stewart|Guy Lapointe|Rob Blake|Zdeno Chara|J.C. Tremblay|Marcel Pronovost|Ebbie Goodfellow|Jacques Laperriere
Vote 8|Emile "Butch" Bouchard|Zdeno Chara|Rob Blake|J.C. Tremblay|Ebbie Goodfellow|Ivan "Ching" Johnson|Jacques Laperriere|Carl Brewer|Hod Stuart|Larry Murphy
Vote 9|Emile "Butch" Bouchard|Zdeno Chara|Rob Blake|Ebbie Goodfellow|Ken Reardon|Albert "Babe" Siebert|Carl Brewer|Larry Murphy|Ernest "Moose" Johnson|Georges "Buck" Boucher
Vote 10|Ken Reardon|Albert "Babe" Siebert|Carl Brewer|Larry Murphy|Georges "Buck" Boucher|Jan Suchy|Alexander Ragulin|Allan Stanley|Fern Flaman|Sylvio Mantha
Vote 11|Ken Reardon|Allan Stanley|Art Coulter|Pat Stapleton|Alexander Ragulin|Fern Flaman|Doug Wilson|Sylvio Mantha|Tom Johnson|Harry Howell
Vote 12|Allan Stanley|Alexander Ragulin|Pat Stapleton|Bill White|Fern Flaman|Sylvio Mantha|Harry Howell|Babe Pratt|Sergei Zubov|Phil Housley

Click to read more...

 

[kmad]

Obvious bias against pre-modern defensemen

 

[tarheelhockey]

Obvious bias against pre-modern defensemen

Or unfamiliarity with them. I'd give him a chance to explain before accusing him of bias.

 

[seventieslord]

Players unique to this list
Leo Reise (66)
Jack Marshall (67)
Glen Harmon (68)
Kevin Lowe (71)
Keith Magnusson (73)
Anders Eldebrink (75)
Craig Ludwig (76)

Magnuson and Ludwig are terrible, but the others are defendable for sure.

note that he ranked these players, but not even top-60 so it's not like we can criticise and question that/