HOH Top 60 Defensemen List & Voting Record - Hawkey Town 18

[overpass]

Hawkey Town 18

Rank | Player
1 | Bobby Orr
2 | Doug Harvey
3 | Eddie Shore
4 | Ray Bourque
5 | Nicklas Lidstrom
6 | Red Kelly
7 | Denis Potvin
8 | Slava Fetisov
9 | Larry Robinson
10 | Chris Chelios
11 | Brad Park
12 | Paul Coffey
13 | King Clancy
14 | Pierre Pilote
15 | Dit Clapper
16 | Earl Seibert
17 | Tim Horton
18 | Sprague Cleghorn
19 | Al MacInnis
20 | Bill Gadsby
21 | Scott Stevens
22 | Chris Pronger
23 | Valeri Vasiliev
24 | Brian Leetch
25 | Borje Salming
26 | Jack Stewart
27 | Bill Quackenbush
28 | Serge Savard
29 | Lionel Conacher
30 | Rod Langway
31 | Mark Howe
32 | Guy Lapointe
33 | Jacques Laperriere
34 | Marcel Pronovost
35 | Scott Niedermayer
36 | Zdeno Chara
37 | Ebbie Goodfellow
38 | J.C. Tremblay
39 | Larry Murphy
40 | Harry Cameron
41 | Eddie Gerard
42 | Sylvio Mantha
43 | Ching Johnson
44 | Tom Johnson
45 | Butch Bouchard
46 | Carl Brewer
47 | Rob Blake
48 | Alexei Kasatonov
49 | Doug Wilson
50 | Ken Reardon
51 | Jan Suchy
52 | Babe Siebert
53 | Moose Johnson
54 | George Boucher
55 | Fern Flaman
56 | Harry Howell
57 | Art Coulter
58 | Alexander Ragulin
59 | Frantisek Pospisil
60 | Lester Patrick
61 | Didier Pitre
62 | Pat Stapleton
63 | Hod Stuart
64 | Herb Gardiner
65 | Bill White
66 | Red Horner
67 | Hap Day
68 | Vladimir Lutchenko
69 | Sergei Zubov
70 | Eric Desjardins
71 | Moose Vasko
72 | Harvey Pulford
73 | Jimmy Thomson
74 | Gus Mortson
75 | Leo Boivin
76 | Si Griffis
77 | Brad McCrimmon
78 | Cy Wentworth
79 | Derian Hatcher
80 | Gary Suter

Players from the Top 60 not to appear on this list
Allan Stanley

Players ranked highest overall on this list
Ebbie Goodfellow (37)

Players ranked lowest overall on this list
Allan Stanley (not listed)

Players unique to this list
Didier Pitre (61)

Round | Rank 1 | Rank 2 | Rank 3 | Rank 4 | Rank 5 | Rank 6 | Rank 7 | Rank 8 | Rank 9 | Rank 10
Vote 1|NONE|||||||||
Vote 2|Red Kelly|Denis Potvin|Slava Fetisov|Chris Chelios|Larry Robinson|King Clancy|Pierre Pilote|Brad Park|Paul Coffey|Al MacInnis
Vote 3|NONE|||||||||
Vote 4|Earl Seibert|Tim Horton|Al MacInnis|Scott Stevens|Dit Clapper|Bill Gadsby|Chris Pronger|Valeri Vasiliev|Brian Leetch|Borje Salming
Vote 5|Bill Gadsby|Dit Clapper|Valeri Vasiliev|Brian Leetch|Borje Salming|Bill Quackenbush|Jack Stewart|Serge Savard|Mark Howe|Rod Langway
Vote 6|Bill Quackenbush|Jack Stewart|Serge Savard|Mark Howe|Eddie Gerard|Marcel Pronovost|Rod Langway|Guy Lapointe|Jacques Laperriere|Lionel Conacher
Vote 7|Jack Stewart|Marcel Pronovost|Alexei Kasatonov|Guy Lapointe|Scott Niedermayer|JC Tremblay|Zdeno Chara|Jacques Laperriere|Lionel Conacher|Rob Blake
Vote 8|Alexei Kasatonov|Ching Johnson|Hod Stuart|Zdeno Chara|Moose Johnson|JC Tremblay|Jacques Laperriere|Rob Blake|Jan Suchy|Larry Murphy
Vote 9|Zdeno Chara|Moose Johnson|Ebbie Goodfellow|Jan Suchy|Rob Blake|Babe Seibert|Larry Murphy|Butch Bouchard|Carl Brewer|Harry Cameron
Vote 10|Jan Suchy|Babe Seibert|Carl Brewer|Fern Flaman|Tom Johnson|George Boucher|Harry Cameron|Sylvio Mantha|Larry Murphy|Doug Wilson
Vote 11|NONE|||||||||
Vote 12|Frantisek Pospisil|Sylvio Mantha|Harvey Pulford|Mike Grant|Alan Stanley|Vladimir Lutchenko|Harry Cameron|Fern Flaman|Bill White|Babe Pratt

Click to read more...

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

Is it surprising to anyone else how uniform a lot of the original lists are?

I was thinking there would be a lot more variation from voter to voter.

 

[TheDevilMadeMe]

Is it surprising to anyone else how uniform a lot of the original lists are?

I was thinking there would be a lot more variation from voter to voter.

It's the damn All Time Draft. The ATD definitely helps increase knowledge of all players but does lead to groupthink

I was happy with our 50/50 split of ATDers/non ATDers.

 

[overpass]

It's the damn All Time Draft. The ATD definitely helps increase knowledge of all players but does lead to groupthink

I was happy with our 50/50 split of ATDers/non ATDers.

Yep.

I should have put another question in the participant survey - do you participate in the All Time Draft?

 

[TheDevilMadeMe]

Also, I think a lot of people (including the ATD itself) use the 2009 and 2008 top 100 lists for the order at the top. So it's no surprise that most people have the same names in the top 20 or so

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

Also, I think a lot of people (including the ATD itself) use the 2009 and 2008 top 100 lists for the order at the top. So it's no surprise that most people have the same names in the top 20 or so

Yeah, I figured the top 25 or so would be similar because of that. I didn't know about the ATD.

 

[Hawkey Town 18]

You guys hit my list on the head with the ATD. I was extremely busy at work up until early December, so I did the Round 1 list pretty quickly and somewhat half-a$$ed, using the ATD draft as a guide.

You will notice a lot of differences between my Round 1 and 2, because I actually put the time in for Round 2