HFBoards TOP 15 Goalie Prospects #1 (redo)

[amnesiac]

forgot Samsonov....

revote please.


edit: and now I put Jarry twice :/

Click to read more...

 

[LordNeverLose]

FWIW here are the 2016 results:
http://hfboards.mandatory.com/showthread.php?t=2123441&highlight=

Results:
1. Thatcher Demko (40.43%) - USA
2. Ilya Sorokin (50.00%) - RUS
3. Ilya Samsonov (45.45%) - RUS
4. Jon Gillies (44.62%) - USA
5. Juuse Saros (46.15%) - FIN
6. Ville Husso (18.75%) - FIN
7. Igor Shestyorkin (20.00%) - RUS
8. Mackenzie Blackwood (22.89%) - CAN
9. Alex Neldeljkovic (18.75%) - USA
10. Malcolm Subban (22.92%) - CAN
11. Anthony Stolarz (25.53%) - USA
12. Eric Comrie (32.56%) - CAN
13. Anton Forsberg (29.27%) - SWE
14. Linus Soderstrom (17.95%) - SWE
15. Laurent Brossoit (23.81%) - CAN
16. Felix Sandstrom (21.28%) - SWE
17. Carter Hart (31.58%) - CAN
18. Tyler Parsons (28.21%) - USA
19. Mason McDonald (35.90%) - CAN
20. Filip Gustavsson (23.33%) - SWE
21. Marcus Hogberg (25.00%) - SWE
22. Tristan Jarry (25.00%) - CAN
23. Joseph Woll (20.00%) - USA
24. Samuel Montembeault (16.67%) - CAN
25. Charlie Lindgren (19.23%) - USA
26. Alex Lyon (23.08%) - USA
27. Zach Fucale (22.86%) - CAN
28. Cal Petersen (18.52%) - USA
29. Kristers Gudlevskis (27.27%) - LAT

 

[Ricklongisland]

Went with Samsonov
Add Linus Soderstrom 18-4 GAA: 1.34 SV%:.943 in Swedish Elite

 

[Pavel Buchnevich]

Shestyorkin, add Huska

 

[Tripod]

Went with Samsonov
Add Linus Soderstrom 18-4 GAA: 1.34 SV%:.943 in Swedish Elite

Yeah Soderstrom and Hart need to be options.

Not their fault NY and Philly have 2 high end goalie prospects.

 

[johna2626]

The only correct answer is Juuse Saros. He's excelled at every level he's been at

 

[The Winter Soldier]

I'm going with Parsons here. There is something magical about this guy that I just have confidence in him when a team needs a save or big game. He is usually there.

 

[Ricklongisland]

Yeah Soderstrom and Hart need to be options.

Not their fault NY and Philly have 2 high end goalie prospects.

Didn't notice Hart. He is a top 10 goalie too

 

[Saabman0508]

As much as I'd love for the Sens to have Oettinger, he was picked by Dallas.

 

[amnesiac]

As much as I'd love for the Sens to have Oettinger, he was picked by Dallas.

 

[Irishguy42]

Any of the Russian trio is the acceptable answer here.

 

[Strait2thecup]

Soderstrom not being an option already makes this bad. He's top 5-7

 

[GingerJesus28]

Where the **** is Carter Hart. Best goalie in the CHL?

 

[GingerJesus28]

Linus Soderstrom??
You didn't include 2 of the best goalie prospects so I can't take this seriously.

 

[thadd]

I honestly don't see what Brossoit has done to belong in the top 15.
I think that there should have been a fair number of goalies whom were drafted since last year who have done more to bring hope to their organization.
In his limited appearances Brossoit was better last year than the year before, but he's still a big question mark for us Oil fans.

 

[LordNeverLose]

Any of Sorokin, Shesty, Samsonov, and Saros are fair answers here

Add Soderstrom, who led the SHL in GAA and was 2nd in SV% (as a 20 y/o)

 

[VoluntaryDom]

samsonov
igor/ilya/juuse
demko

 

[Lays]

Soderstrom not being an option already makes this bad. He's top 5-7

Where the **** is Carter Hart. Best goalie in the CHL?

It's not like they'd win this anyway he can add them in later

 

[Lays]

Any of Sorokin, Shesty, Samsonov, and Saros are fair answers here

Add Soderstrom, who led the SHL in GAA and was 2nd in SV% (as a 20 y/o)

This. It's a toss up between all of them. Any order you put them in can end up being the same backwards.

 

[RememberTheName]

Parsons. Wait, why did I vote him. I jut blanked while voting. I should have went Sorokin
Where the hell is Blackwood. He got 8th last year and improved MASSIVELY this season

 

[Tkachuk Norris]

Samsonov or Parsons IMO.

I think Parsons has a lot of Jon Quick in his game. And he's clutch to the max.

 

[MardyBum]

Saros for me, then comes a run of KHLers.

 

[Cotton]

Add Joe Woll.

 

[amnesiac]

Parsons. Wait, why did I vote him. I jut blanked while voting. I should have went Sorokin
Where the hell is Blackwood. He got 8th last year and improved MASSIVELY this season

THN has him as NJ's 9th best prospect... .907 SV% in the A last season wasnt that impressive