Greatest Goalie of All Time #8

Brodeur won with 14 votes and Gardiner will be added next. add Brimsek

#1.Roy(40.70%)
#2.Sawchuk(36.00%)
#3.Plante(38.16%)
#4.Hasek(32.05%)
#5.Hall(37.84%)
#6.Dryden(38.61%)
#7.Brodeur(31.11%)

 

Add Brimsek

 

Vote Parent, add Brimsek.

 

Bill Durnan, add Brismek

 

Durnan, add Fhur

 

You're going to spell "Fuhr" right eventually in one of these threads. I just know it.

 

Speling wus nevr mi forteh

 

Durnan.

 

Voted Tretiak, again.

 

Durnan, add Brimsek.

 

For the third time running.

Hainsworth add Brimsek.

 

I forgot to mention that Hockey Outsider couldn't take part in this poll but he sent me a pm and he is voting for Durnan. So whatever Durnan finishes with I will have to add one more vote to his total.

 

I guess you also vote for the Green Party

 

As in the last two polls, I will vote for Tretiak. I think this is my sixth time saying ADD BRIMSEK!!

 

Provincially, yes. Federally, no, I vote Conservative in a leftist hotbed.

 

Tretiak add Brimsek.

 

Add Belfour

 

Belfour too!

Come on guys vote for Durnan!!!!

 

Bill Durnan

 

Durnan couldn't overcome Broda.

 

Tretiak, add Belfour.

 

Personally I have a big problem with non-NHL goalies being included in this poll. There really is very little basis of comparison and invariably, some great European goalies like the mid 70's Czech goalies will get ignored because they never got the press Tretiak got in the west.

 

Good point. Jiri Holecek was named the top goalie at the World Championships more times than Tretiak. That tournament was considered the most important one in Europe.

 

Only marginally different than the bias against early and pre-NHLers like Benedict.

 

Vladislav Tretiak