Greatest Goalie of All time #2

[canucksfan]

Roy won with 35 votes and Bernie Parent will be added next. I am voting for Plante and add Broda.

#1.Roy(40.70%)

Click to read more...

 

[Psycho Papa Joe]

Plante, add Broda

 

[Nalyd Psycho]

Once again, voted Sawchuk, add Benedict.

#1.Roy(40.70%)

Boo! Hiss!

 

[BM67]

Plante, add Broda

 

[Bluesfan1981]

Plante, add Benedict.

 

[Bear of Bad News]

Plante, add Broda.

 

[JWINK19]

Once again, Sawchuk. Add Brimsek.

 

[Wisent]

Once again, voted Sawchuk, add Benedict.



Boo! Hiss!

Second. The Boo! Hiss! I mean.

 

[Big Phil]

Wow Brodeur is second with 9 votes compared to Sawchuks 10. No way Brodeur is #2 all time though. Top 5 all time isnt out of the question but he's not Sawchuk.

 

[Bluesfan1981]

Wow Brodeur is second with 9 votes compared to Sawchuks 10. No way Brodeur is #2 all time though. Top 5 all time isnt out of the question but he's not Sawchuk.

Absolutely. This poll already got screwed with Roy winning #1, and winning it easily, and now Brodeur is threatening to win #2.

 

[EagleBelfour]

Plante, add Benedict.

Like the wise man said.

 

[19nazzy]

Absolutely. This poll already got screwed with Roy winning #1, and winning it easily

 

[canucksfan]

Absolutely. This poll already got screwed with Roy winning #1, and winning it easily, and now Brodeur is threatening to win #2.

I don't mind Roy being #1. When I started this poll I knew that Roy will be first. I have him fourth on my list: Hall, Sawchuk and Plante being ahead of him. However, Brodeur isn't even close to being #2. I would put Brodeur around 8th or the 9th spot. It depends on what he does in the next couple of years and he might climb up.

I said this in the other thread Hall must be the most underrated player ever. He only has one vote. He played 502 consecutive games as a goalie. What's amazing about that is he didn't have a mask. He was named first team all-star seven times. He won a Conne Smythe playing for the Blues. He was the only reason why the Blues reached the Finals that year. He also has three Vezina's.

 

[Bluesfan1981]

I don't mind Roy being #1. When I started this poll I knew that Roy will be first. I have him fourth on my list: Hall, Sawchuk and Plante being ahead of him.

I do, because he's overrated. Even though Roy is the best I've seen, I didn't vote for him because after studying it closely, I can't see how he comes out ahead of Plante and Sawchuk. Roy and Hall is very close, I think it could go either way.

 

[Habsfan 32]

Terry Sawchuk

 

[Zetterberg4Captain*]

Sawchuk, add Benedict.

 

[Nalyd Psycho]

I don't mind Roy being #1. When I started this poll I knew that Roy will be first. I have him fourth on my list: Hall, Sawchuk and Plante being ahead of him. However, Brodeur isn't even close to being #2. I would put Brodeur around 8th or the 9th spot. It depends on what he does in the next couple of years and he might climb up.

I said this in the other thread Hall must be the most underrated player ever. He only has one vote. He played 502 consecutive games as a goalie. What's amazing about that is he didn't have a mask. He was named first team all-star seven times. He won a Conne Smythe playing for the Blues. He was the only reason why the Blues reached the Finals that year. He also has three Vezina's.

Well, one of two reasons. The other being that young upstart of a coach the Blues had.

I to don't have a problem with Roy winning. He doesn't deserve it as there is no way he's better than Sawchuk or Plante. But it's not totally out of the question. It's just very short sighted and poorly researched. And for my money, Hasek's better.

But Broduer? I like the guy and often defend him around here. But I sturggle to put him top 10. There are two guys not on the list now that are better IMO in Benedict and Broda.

 

[B Boarding]

If Hasek's not voted the best goalie ever I'm not going to take any discussions regarding goalies serious in this forum. I don't care about the number of cups, because hockey is a team sport. But if you look at what Hasek did in 94-01 he is up there with Lemieux, Gretzky and Orr in pure dominance and individual awards. And he´s prime was just as long as Orr's!

 

[Nalyd Psycho]

His excellence isn't above and beyond Sawchuk, Hall and Plante, and they all had significantly more longevity.

 

[Bear of Bad News]

If Hasek's not voted the best goalie ever I'm not going to take any discussions regarding goalies serious in this forum. I don't care about the number of cups, because hockey is a team sport. But if you look at what Hasek did in 94-01 he is up there with Lemieux, Gretzky and Orr in pure dominance and individual awards. And he´s prime was just as long as Orr's!

http://hfboards.com/showpost.php?p=6274659&postcount=71

 

[#66]

If Hasek's not voted the best goalie ever I'm not going to take any discussions regarding goalies serious in this forum. I don't care about the number of cups, because hockey is a team sport. But if you look at what Hasek did in 94-01 he is up there with Lemieux, Gretzky and Orr in pure dominance and individual awards. And he´s prime was just as long as Orr's!

And if you look at what Hall did, on a good team not a great one, you'll see that his dominance was to the same degree as Hasek's but longer.

 

[Canucks5551]

Voted Sawchuk

 

[Talent Analyst]

Terry Sawchuk

 

[God Bless Canada]

If Hasek's not voted the best goalie ever I'm not going to take any discussions regarding goalies serious in this forum. I don't care about the number of cups, because hockey is a team sport. But if you look at what Hasek did in 94-01 he is up there with Lemieux, Gretzky and Orr in pure dominance and individual awards. And he´s prime was just as long as Orr's!

Gretzky, Lemieux and Orr each won two Conn Smythe Trophies during their peak. Hasek has none.

 

[EagleBelfour]

If Sawchuk wins it, Plante better be third!

And for the Hasek lovers, Hall and Hainsworth should come before (even though it won't happen) and maybe Tretiak.