Goalies

[Slapshot_11]

How would you rank these goalie prospects ?

Carey Price
Tuukka Rask
Leland Irving
Jonathan Bernier
Justin Pogge
Cory Schneider
Josh Harding
Al Montoya

Click to read more...

 

[Louis Houde]

Tuukka Rask
Carey Price
Josh Harding
Al Montoya
Jonathan Bernier
Justin Pogge
Cory Schneider
Leland Irving

 

[Marco Corleone]

Carey Price
Tuukka Rask
Jonathan Bernier
Leland Irving
Cory Schneider
Justin Pogge
Al Montoya
Josh Harding

 

[Redwingsfan]

tuukka rask
josh harding
carey price
jonathan bernier
al montoya
cory schneider
justin pogge
leland irving

 

[Redwingsfan]

Carey Price
Tuukka Rask
Jonathan Bernier
Leland Irving
Cory Schneider
Justin Pogge
Al Montoya
Josh Harding

harding last

 

[Riffo*]

Tuukka Rask
Justin Pogge
Josh Harding
Carey Price
Al Montoya
Cory Schneider
Leland Irving
Jonathan Bernier

 

[shaner8989]

Price
Rask
Pogge
Montoya
Harding
Schnieder
Berneir
Irving

 

[Vyse64]

Price
Rask
Montoya
Harding
Bernier
Irving
Pogge
Schnieder

 

[cdnhky1]

How would you rank these goalie prospects ?

Carey Price
Tuukka Rask
Leland Irving
Jonathan Bernier
Justin Pogge
Cory Schneider
Josh Harding
Al Montoya

Carey Price
Tuukka Rask
Jonathan Bernier
Justin Pogge
Cory Schneider
Josh Harding
Leland Irving
Al Montoya

 

[Buffalo87]

May I ask, what exactly has Rask done to be ranked that high? I would have a VERY hard time ranking him over Harding or Price, and 2 or 3 other guys would be debatable.

 

[friction]

Haha none of these are even remotely close to each other. My take:

Carey Price
Josh Harding
Al Montoya
Jonathan Bernier
Tuukka Rask
Justin Pogge
Leland Irving
Cory Schneider

 

[AnThGrt]

Just wondering how Irving is infront of Bernier when Bernier won goalie of the year led his team to the cup and has been 1st star in all three memorial cup games though losing two of the games. My ranking:

Carey Price
Josh Harding
Jonathan Bernier
Tuukka Rask
Al Montoya
Leland Irving
Justin Pogge
Cory Schneider

 

[Hunter Gathers]

Carey Price
Tuukka Rask
Jonathan Bernier
Justin Pogge
Cory Schneider
Josh Harding
Leland Irving
Al Montoya

 

[Hunter Gathers]

May I ask, what exactly has Rask done to be ranked that high? I would have a VERY hard time ranking him over Harding or Price, and 2 or 3 other guys would be debatable.

What has Pogge, Bernier, or Irving done also?

 

[a99tobe]

What has Pogge, Bernier, or Irving done also?

Just wondering how Irving is infront of Bernier when Bernier won goalie of the year led his team to the cup and has been 1st star in all three memorial cup games though losing two of the games.

That is what Bernier has done.

 

[Hunter Gathers]

That is what Bernier has done.

Yes, and Al Montoya has won a gold medal and was named to the AHL All-Star team as a rookie (and I believe this year as well).

He's played great in the AHL against men. Not against boys like Bernier is doing.

The CHL goalies should not be above much more proven guys like Harding and Montoya, both of whom are far advanced and superior to guys like Leland and Bernier so far.

 

[Johnnybegood13]

I need to play to homer roll i guess

Irving should be top 3 on that list based on a 3 year career with a GAA of 1.82

And any list without Matt Keetley is cr@p

 

[Maitz]

Tuuka Rask
Carey Price
Josh Harding
Al Montoya
Justin Pogge
Jonathan Bernier
Corey Schneider
Leland Irving

 

[Zelepukin Lives]

Carey Price
Josh Harding
Al Montoya
Tuuka Rask
Leland Irving
Jonathan Bernier
Justin Pogge
Corey Schneider

 

[kovy-hawa]

tuukka rask
SVS%
2003-2004 Finland U18 WJC-18 5 1.61 .927 jr

2004-2005 Ilves SM-Liiga 4 4.46 .875 sr

Finland U20 WJC-20 5 2.96 . 902 jr

Finland U18 WJC-18 5 3.02 . 910 jr

2005-2006 Ilves SM-Liiga 30 2.09 .926 sr

Finland U20 WJC-20 6 2.11 .940 jr

2006-2007 Ilves SM-Liiga 49 2.38 .928 sr


price
League GP GAA SVS%
2002-2003 Tri-City Americans WHL 1 6.00 .857 jr

2003-2004 Tri-City Americans WHL 28 2.38 .915 jr

2004-2005 Tri-City Americans WHL 63 2.34 .920 jr

Canada U18 WJC-18 4 2.65 .894 jr

2005-2006 Tri-City Americans WHL 55 2.87 .906 jr

2006-2007 Tri-City Americans WHL 46 2.45 .917 jr

 

[Holden Caulfield]

Jonthan Bernier
Tuukka Rask
Leland Irving
Carey Price
Al Montoya

Josh Harding
Cory Schneider


Justin Pogge

 

[19 for president]

How would you guys say Jimmy Howard stacks up to these guys? Top end, middle, bottom?

 

[Mr. Hab]

How would you guys say Jimmy Howard stacks up to these guys? Top end, middle, bottom?

The homer HAB fan will take a crack at this!! Here goes (while adding Howard, Frazee, etc...).


1. Carey Price/Tuukka Rask (imo, both are potential franchise goalies)
2. Tuukka Rask/Carey Price
3. Josh Harding (future #1 goalie of Minnesota after solid #1 goalie Fernandez)
4. Al Montoya
5. Jonathan Bernier
6. Leland Irving
7. Jeff Frazee
8. Pavelec
9. Jimmy Howard
10. Varlamov
11. Justin Pogge
12. Cory Schneider

 

[Chrisd]

Harding and Price are the 2 best for my money...

Price has shown it in the WHL, and AHL.

Harding has shown it at every level including the NHL where he's been downright scary when he's got his chances. Backstrom will not hold him off too long.

 

[Redwingsfan]

May I ask, what exactly has Rask done to be ranked that high? I would have a VERY hard time ranking him over Harding or Price, and 2 or 3 other guys would be debatable.

not much. other then being one of the best goalies in the finnish league two years in a row (against men) at age 18 and 19.


IMO that's a huge accomplishment