The lineup just isn't good enough. I don't know how anyone could argue otherwise. Its on Chiarelli. He needs to be held accountable.
I don't think players have given up. I'm always suspicious of that claim and feel that it gets thrown out too often. I think the bold might more accurately be stated 'a lineup that just isn't good enough'. But still, there is enough talent on the team to run a PP and a PK. The fact that the Oilers remain a woeful special teams club is surely partly on the coaching staff.
I would remove Khaira's name from that list. He has looked decent to good in recent games. At least he is trying to use his skill set and being somewhat effective.
But let's maybe look a little further up the lineup as well. What has Draisaitl done lately? Seven shots on goal in the last five games combined. A minus player in several of those games. Big fat donuts across the board against the Leafs and Yotes. Zero PP points. I mean I guess he at least remains able to tap in those McDavid gifts which isn't nothing, but aren't you expecting a lot more? I was.
Like I said above I don't necessarily subscribe to your theory that players have given up - particularly the less talented half of the roster (the names you mention above) who must realize that this is probably their one and only NHL chance. But if I had to pick a guy who looks like he's given up, checked out, whatever, I hate to say it but Draisaitl's name would be one that comes to mind.
Do I think Drai is playing well or to his capability? No.
You just confirmed my whole point. When go to players like Draisaitl even McD look like they have checked out the illustration of what is occurring is very evident. Even good players on this club are not being good players. This albeit, is not a new theme, just that new players have started to recognize the futility of this org. That should be horrifying to any Oiler fan if not the league itself. The worst fears that the Oilers would wreck a player like McD were often expressed. (note I am NOT saying this occurs just that on some nights, in some periods, it resembles what it would look like)
Now that's not to critique those players, its natural for players to play up or down depending on what they feel the teams chances of success are. Even McD's effort last night was token. If they were being honest, which almost never happens in hockey and/or is never asked I'm sure they are both disgusted with playing with the likes of Caggiulia as a third. Or Letestu on the PP, repeat, lather, rinse.
Its on Chia, always, that we have a team with players like McD, Drai, Talbot and he builds such holes around it.
Heres some interesting and random asides. In one game earlier this season the Oilers take a penalty in a game they are leading. Wayne Gretzky is in attendance and puts his head in his hands as if something terrible has occurred. The reaction seemed really off to me and overstating the event on the ice. Except that Wayne would be in a position to know how vulnerable the psyche of this lineup was. That it was cymbal crash away from giving up at any moment. That's what I got from that. The Oilers ended up giving up a few more goals and losing that game. I'll never forget the moment because Waynes reaction perfectly foreshadowed the team steering into the ditch that night. An indication to me that something was really wrong under the surface. I haven't seen Wayne as much recently either. Maybe already tiring of what is going on here.
Heres an odd one. McD's parents have stopped showing up. First the father, now the mother too. I'm not reading anything in, it just strikes me that there is still muted excitement about their son playing here, there always has been. On the same night I get to see Auston Matthews father looking ecstatic and thrilled watching his son play for the Maple Leafs. (you know, the way Nurse's Father looks seeing Darnell play) A scene we've never got from McD's father who has been stoic at best. I look at stuff like that occasionally because in pro anything you never really get the truth abut what a player or entourage actually thinks. you get pad answers, "Its great here, couldn't be more excited, such a great org history" etc.
This is really going off the rails.