I'd take Reinhart 1st overall. Lots of good defensemen go in later rounds: Chara at 56, Keith at 54th, Weber 49th, Karlsson 15th, Letang 62nd ect. That's not even mentioning the late round fliers like Buff, Enstrom, Markov ect.
Lots of busts/disappointments early: Hickey 4th, Erik Johnson 1st, Jack Johnson 3rd, Brian Lee 9th, Barker 3rd, Valabik 10th ect.
Take elite forwards early in the 1st round since they're easiest to predict, then draft goalies and defensemen in subsequent rounds. Gilles looks better than Irving ever did, and Brodie looks better than Pelech ever did.
I really like what Feaster has done taking forwards in the 1st round and skilled defensemen with flaws later. I think at least one of Culkin, Kulak and Roy will play in our top 4 one day.