Proposal: (EMD) - [TOR) - Larson for Nylander (Shakened Not Stireed)

[ChaoticOrange]

Nylander > Henrique and Vatanen >> Larsson. Jones >>> Larsson.

Mid 1st + 2nd + 2nd/Hamilton
Mid 1st + 2nd + 2nd/Hamonic
2nd + 2nd/Boychuk
Pokka + garbage/Leddy
Setoguchi + Coyle + late 1st/Burns + 2nd

Just because your GM is actively sabotaging your franchise doesn't mean it's normal for others to do so. No sane GM would pay a top line forward for Larsson

Vatanen is not better at anything but offense than Larsson. If you value your defensive zone at all you’d rather have Larsson 100 times out of 100. Jones is very good but Johansen is a legit 1C. Nylander is not worth a guy like Jones, even back when he was still emerging.

Hamonic is awful. Boychuk was old and a UFA. Leddy is a proud green jacket owner because he needs a map in his own zone.

Burns was a forward when the Sharks traded for him ancient history is fun though. The only good deal there for the team giving up the assets is the Hamilton deal. If you can replicate that go nuts.

 

[Brock Radunske]

Both teams need shake up.

Shaken not Stirred.

James Bond. James, Bond.

Who says no?

Not who you think.

Think About It.

Haha, you knew the answer to this before you even posted it but just in case...

Hell no!
- Toronto

 

[Legend123]

Going from hall to nylander is quite sad. For that reason alone, Oilers won't do it althou they would be really stupid.
Chia must have heard of salvage value. Nylander is the perfect salvage value.

 

[Brock Radunske]

Adam Larsson is arguably a below average NHL defender.

As a 4th overall pick to have only reached a career high of 24 points in his 7 NHL seasons is absolutely pathetic. It actually qualifies him as a bust when you factor in his draft position.

Oilers really got hosed in that trade, easily one of the top 10 worst trades in NHL history.

Where would you rank Reinhardt for the pick that landed Barzal?

 

[Scott Stevens]

It’s a ham and cheese sandwich with French toast as the bread. I think it would have to be nurse for the conversation to start

I prefer they hold the icing sugar and whatever else may make it sweeter than savory. I really do like the savory version.

 

[therealkoho]

You guys are hilarious.

‘Kapanen/JVR’s rights/Tyler Bozak/Josh Leivo have LOADS of value,! Him and other spare crap is totally a fair offer for a top four defenceman!’

‘Top four defenceman? Pfft you’d have to add your top ten first or a top six C to be worth our one dimensional winger’

Jones/Johansen
Hall/Larsson
Henrique/Vatanen

no more hilarious then your obvious and sad jests my friend

Nylander for OEL isn't all that crazy and a lot less crazy the Nylander straight up for Adam Larsson who like Tanev in Vancouver are nothing the Leafs need based on the game they play

 

[TorontoTrades]

disgusting. Unless Drai or McDavid are involved no way for Nylander to be in involved. AKA won't happen.

 

[Superlative Soup]

no more hilarious then your obvious and sad jests my friend

Nylander for OEL isn't all that crazy and a lot less crazy the Nylander straight up for Adam Larsson who like Tanev in Vancouver are nothing the Leafs need based on the game they play

Is the game they play tire fire in their own zone?

 

[cwede]

EO hoping someone else will make the same deal they did?
Larsson's value has not increased since EO lost that deal ...

 

[KirkAlbuquerque]

Who the hell is EMD

You know, the Emdonton Oliers

 

[GOilers88]

Adam Larsson is arguably a below average NHL defender.

As a 4th overall pick to have only reached a career high of 24 points in his 7 NHL seasons is absolutely pathetic. It actually qualifies him as a bust when you factor in his draft position.

Oilers really got hosed in that trade, easily one of the top 10 worst trades in NHL history.

This is easily one of the most ridiculous things I've ever seen. You either have to be joking and I missed it, or you're totally clueless. Those are your only two options.

 

[Tad Mikowsky]

Both teams need shake up.

Shaken not Stirred.

James Bond. James, Bond.

Who says no?

Not who you think.

Think About It.

Time to retire the Genuis part of your user name.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

no more hilarious then your obvious and sad jests my friend

Nylander for OEL isn't all that crazy and a lot less crazy the Nylander straight up for Adam Larsson who like Tanev in Vancouver are nothing the Leafs need based on the game they play

Uh, yeah, it’s pretty crazy. Wingers don’t return #1 defencemen.

 

[Morgs]

I'd literally rather stab myself in the eye than be a Leaf fan if we made this trade.

 

[Dzonna]

Both teams need shake up.

Shaken not Stirred.

James Bond. James, Bond.

Who says no?

Not who you think.

Think About It.

Johnson zaitzev 2nd and Lou hangs up by saying you’re welcome Edmonton

 

[Dzonna]

I'd literally rather stab myself in the eye than be a Leaf fan if we made this trade.

That was literally my post but a little worse than a simple eye stabbing, so I decided on a different route

 

[LeafFever]

First of all, the Leafs don't need a "shake-up" at all. they are doing fine. Edmonton? Sure.
The Leafs won't make the same mistake as the Oilers did and trade a young forward with great talent fora top 4 D.

 

[member 157595]

Awful for Toronto. Doesn't make sense to move Nylander for a good but low-upside player like Larsson.

 

[nhlfan1991]

Larson

Then add your first. Nylander is worth a ****ton more than a 4th dman.

Larson would be your best dmen. I think it's a fair deal

 

[ole ole]

Adam Larsson is arguably a below average NHL defender.

As a 4th overall pick to have only reached a career high of 24 points in his 7 NHL seasons is absolutely pathetic. It actually qualifies him as a bust when you factor in his draft position.

Oilers really got hosed in that trade, easily one of the top 10 worst trades in NHL history.

Don't agree with Larsson being a bust because he's more of a defensive D-Man but the trade ,Yes was horrendous for the Oilers.
Also yes the Leafs are in bad need for Defense but i believe that Nylander has > value than Larsson.

 

[The List Of Jericho]

"Montecristo" respond to your post"

You sound like a vampire. Or a cheese.

Please be real.

We are meaning Toronto Nylander.

Well if Buffalo says no for Alex than your certainly not getting William

 

[The List Of Jericho]

Larson

Larson would be your best dmen. I think it's a fair deal

You really enjoy trolling, Larsson would not be our best defeceman, in fact you could make an argument he would be 3 or even 4 on the Leafs

 

[Morbo]

Sorry, Leafs aren't interested in bailing Chia out of his terrible Hall trade.

 

[glucker]

You don’t make the Hall for Larsson deal better by throwing needs to the wind and dealing Larsson for a much less dominant winger.

We badly needed a guy like Larsson. Trading Larsson for Nylander just puts us back to square 1 of having garbage RHD, badly needing to address that need, except now we have Nylander instead of Hall.

Sooner just keep Larsson.

Trading Hall for Larsson was an awful deal... what you traded him for should have no baring on what you will accept for him in a trade, it’s a sunk cost. Larson also isn’t a good enough defenseman to really worry about the hole it leaves when you’re getting a top line winger, who could very well develop into a C if need be, as he’s already been counted on in that role for TO, and did quite well.

The only thing that should be keeping Edmonton is the value of the picks they’d have to give up to convince TO to do this.

 

[glucker]

Larson

Larson would be your best dmen. I think it's a fair deal

He’d definitely be our best dman on the right side of the third pairing.