Well yes, the point was to share an opinion. What was the point of you bringing up anyone other than the two listed in the poll? I imagine it was to share an opinion.
I doubt you’ve seen half of these kids enough to really build an informed opinion on who’s better than who, I doubt most have, so basing it upon the numbers it indicates that no, they aren’t on a different tier.
And while development isn’t linear, none of these other kids have an advantage quite as large as a McDavid, or Bergeron and Marchand to amplify their totals. Well, Rantanen has magically gone PPG in the same season Mackinnons broke out, must be coincidental
. Matthews has been injured this year and what you know, Nylander isn’t producing as much... also completely unrelated
.
So no, I completely disagree with you that they are on different tiers.