Excellent work, HO, not just for the numbers, but for the refreshing caveat that these are simply numbers, and not the be-all and end-all for player evaluation. (A reality that is often lost on too many posters around here). There are definitely some surprises (never would have thought Zubov would be so high, or that Howe and Stevens would be tied), but there are many who wound up where you'd expect to see them (notably McCrimmon, Foote and Langway).
Do you have a list for defencemen with the fewest ES goals against who played over 400 NHL games? I believe Russell played the most of anyone on that list at 396 games.
Definitely agreed. Numbers can be used to support an argument or position, but they aren't arguments on their own.
Langway's rank is even more impressive when you consider the era he played in.
Here's the list for players with at least 400 games played. (I should have mentioned earlier that these stats are only current through the 2002-03 season).
Name GP ESGA GPG
Peter Popovic 485 244 0.50
Aaron Miller 447 245 0.55
Robert Dirk 402 249 0.62
Craig Rivet 437 251 0.57
Darren Van Impe 411 253 0.62
Jason Marshall 434 254 0.59
Aaron Ward 432 256 0.59
Rhett Warrener 483 257 0.53
Alexander Karpovtsev 458 259 0.57
Rick Chartraw 420 260 0.62
Jay McKee 464 262 0.56
Aki Berg 452 276 0.61
Greg Hawgood 474 278 0.59
Bob Boughner 535 280 0.52
Janne Laukkanen 407 280 0.69
Jon Klemm 521 281 0.54
Jaroslav Modry 411 284 0.69
Todd Simpson 467 287 0.61
Drake Berehowsky 493 288 0.58
Vladimir Konstantinov 446 288 0.65
Ruslan Salei 434 289 0.67
Cale Hulse 498 297 0.60
Jassen Cullimore 445 297 0.67
Derek Morris 418 298 0.71
Not surprisingly, most of the players are from the dead puck era. This is a pretty good list though; a lot of very solid stay-at-home defenders are on here (and, Aki Berg).
I was very surprised when I saw Belak on this list, but consider the context in which he plays.
1. He played most of his career in the dead-puck era, which artificially lowers his GPG ratio.
2. He generally gets easy matchups. I can't remember many times that Belak had to shut down players like Kovalchuk, Alfredsson, Sakic, etc. Again, since he faces easier (lower-scoring) opposition, his GPG is lowered.
3. The Leafs are generally above-average defensively (taking into account both defense and goaltending), so his GPG is probably slighly lowered by this.
4. Belak probably gets around 8 minutes of ES ice time per game while top defenders can get 15-20. Staying on the ice for .34 goals per 8 minutes worse than .77 (Pronger), .80 (Lidstrom) or .74 (Niedermayer) in 20 ES minutes per game.
In short, Belak's "unadjusted" numbers look great, but they're not so good once you consider the context.
==
I'll post the list for best/worst forwards later today.