Whatever Man*
Guest
With all the player comparisons being done, there should be some sort of criteria for making them. Certain things about a player or his carreer that are what you judge him on.
This will be a growing list.
So if anything is missing, just say what it is.
Criteria:
I would like to eventually use a 1-100 scale (10, 25, 50, doesn't really matter) for each criteria, where the player who is at the top of the category is 100 and the rest are judged from there.
Example:
Longevity - Gordie Howe would be 100, Messier would likely be mid 90's, Francis mid to low 90's, Andreychuk low 90's, etc.
Skaters Criteria:
1. Longevity
2. Offense
3. Defense
4. Leadership
5. Awards
6. Championships
7. Dominance of peers
8. Records
9. Puck Control
10. Stick handling
11. Passing
12. Goal Scoring
13. Shot - Accuracy + Power + ??
14. Power - strength + balance + toughess + ??
15. Points per Game - Regular Season
16. Points per Game - Post Season
17. +/-
18. Clutch Performances
19. Speed
20. Agility
21. Other skating Ablities - Acceleration, Balance, Poise, Reverse, Transition
22. Work Ethic
23. Playoff Performance - Elevated game
24. Creativity
25. All-Star - Games, 1st Team, 2nd Team
26. Heart & Soul - Playing hurt etc.
27.
Goaltending Criteria:
1. Longevity
2. Leadership
3. Clutch Performances
5. Awards
6. Championships
7. Dominance of peers
8. Records
9. Rebound/Puck Control
10. Stick handling/Poke Check
11. Passing
12. Glove/Blocker
13. Pads
14. Durability
15. Speed
16. Agility
17. Flexibility
18. Work Ethic
19. Playoff Performance - Elevated Game
20. All-Star - Games, 1st Team, 2nd Team
21. Heart & Soul
22.
Others.....
This will be a growing list.
So if anything is missing, just say what it is.
Criteria:
I would like to eventually use a 1-100 scale (10, 25, 50, doesn't really matter) for each criteria, where the player who is at the top of the category is 100 and the rest are judged from there.
Example:
Longevity - Gordie Howe would be 100, Messier would likely be mid 90's, Francis mid to low 90's, Andreychuk low 90's, etc.
Skaters Criteria:
1. Longevity
2. Offense
3. Defense
4. Leadership
5. Awards
6. Championships
7. Dominance of peers
8. Records
9. Puck Control
10. Stick handling
11. Passing
12. Goal Scoring
13. Shot - Accuracy + Power + ??
14. Power - strength + balance + toughess + ??
15. Points per Game - Regular Season
16. Points per Game - Post Season
17. +/-
18. Clutch Performances
19. Speed
20. Agility
21. Other skating Ablities - Acceleration, Balance, Poise, Reverse, Transition
22. Work Ethic
23. Playoff Performance - Elevated game
24. Creativity
25. All-Star - Games, 1st Team, 2nd Team
26. Heart & Soul - Playing hurt etc.
27.
Goaltending Criteria:
1. Longevity
2. Leadership
3. Clutch Performances
5. Awards
6. Championships
7. Dominance of peers
8. Records
9. Rebound/Puck Control
10. Stick handling/Poke Check
11. Passing
12. Glove/Blocker
13. Pads
14. Durability
15. Speed
16. Agility
17. Flexibility
18. Work Ethic
19. Playoff Performance - Elevated Game
20. All-Star - Games, 1st Team, 2nd Team
21. Heart & Soul
22.
Others.....
Last edited by a moderator: