I really don’t have a horse in this race but I love the fact that you just enraged die hard fans everywhere. That’s the one thing I will say about Star Wars is that it has the biggest fan base of people who will trash the trailers and how much sacralige it is the recast characters but in the same sentence will tell you that they preordered their imax tickets and will probably see the movie 4-5 times in theaters.
I'm pretty much in that boat. I am a die hard Star Wars fan, grew up watching the originals on repeat and even found some positive things in the prequels and still enjoy watching them (I know I'm in the minority). The new Disney films have been a mixed bag for me, but I know I will still be there opening night for Solo which is coming up, and episode 9 in a couple years.
Star Wars is a franchise that is where it is because of nostalgia, not because it's really a particularly good series. It's over exposed and will be milked for decades because of said nostalgia. It was the "Avatar" of it's time in regards to special effects and also like Avatar, it doesn't change that it's completely overhyped with a very weak story.
Sure people enjoy Star Wars and they have a massive fanbase but so do all of the sci fi franchises, like Doctor Who and Star Trek for instance. Star Wars certainly isn't unique in that sense either.
Nostalgia has gone a long way in keeping Star Wars in the mainstream of culture and entertainment. No denying that. There are legitimately only two great Star Wars films (the original, and The Empire Strikes Back) that have fueled that nostalgia. While I agree that the original Star Wars can somewhat be considered "the Avatar of its time" even saying that would be underestimating the impact which Star Wars had on film and culture. Avatar brought 3D back into the spotlight and some new tools to the visual effects toolbox but that is about it. The film is entirely forgettable and I am not sure how much longer that the 3D format will be relevant. Beyond that it was just a very expensive rendition of Gone with the Wolves and Fern Gully in regards to its story structure, characters, and general plot. Star Wars on the other hand essentially built the toolbox for future filmmakers to use and completely mainlined itself immediately into the zeitgiest. It is not heralded for its wholly original or complex story. It is held in such high regard because of the melding of the multiple influences that inspired Lucas into one cohesive, unique, rockrolling sci-fi fairy tale. Lucas used character and story tropes that have existed since we started telling stories-tropes that are inherently a part of our human experience. Most of the great mythic and grand adventures we know all usually wear these story tropes on their sleeves and use it as a sort of short hand to tell their stories.
And the fanbases of Doctor Who and Star Trek pales in comparison to what is Star Wars fandom precisely because of its universal appeal and easily recognizable mythic story elements.
My biggest thing is I hate watching things twice so while I've seen all the other star wars movies, Harry Potter and lord of the rings I'll never quite understand the fandom when it comes to watching stuff over and over again. I hated the lord of the rings series. I enjoyed the hobbit trilogy more but even that was meh for me. I'm just not into that genre and it's why I haven't bothered watching game of thrones either.
I don't even know where to start with this one. I couldn't imagine seeing a great movie and then going: "Now I never need to see that again." It takes multiple viewings to really "get" a movie and I am not talking about understanding the plot or character motivation. Great movies have so much more to offer than simply the first initial reaction. What are the themes at play? What was the writer saying with that scene? Why did the director choose that shot there? I never noticed the music comes in at that part! I didn't get that that part was foreshadowing that part! And the such. Now I am kinda a movie buff so I do comprehend how movies are just one form of entertainment among many for some to enjoy on a surface level and then never think of again. I am kinda that way with music. I like what I like but don't look into anything more beyond that.
And in no universe is the Hobbit trilogy better than Lord of the Rings.
I quite enjoyed Infinity War. There were a couple little things that kind of annoyed me, but that's pretty much any movie. I still think I'd rank the first Avengers movie slightly higher, but this was way better than Age of Ultron, which was boring as hell for me.
Infinity War was probably my favorite Marvel movie thus far. Just a great ride that finally felt like there was real stakes for our characters. You definitely need to see at least the brunt of the previous films to get the whole impact however. I need to see it again because I went at some unholy hour to originally see it. Just waiting for the wife to see some of the other movies and then we can see it.