They are where they were both slated to be now. McDavid was the consensus #1 pick, a generational talent, no question he'd go first in the draft. Eichel would go first in every draft year leading back to Tavares, and he might have gone first in that one. Both exceptional players, but there's clear separation between them, as predicted. Either way you'd have to be jumping for joy to have Jack or Connor--look at the Oilers meh run of number 1 overalls, Eichel is the kind of guy that can still turn a franchise around, unlike the RNH/Hall/Yakupovs. Having said that--Eichel is no McDavid, never will be.
Edit: Connor with 5th goal, just now. 2nd point of the game. He's PPG in 8 games.