CaberFan said:It could be Sundin vs Deadmarsh (including concussions) and the vote would still go the same way
Flames Draft Watcher said:I think I know how this will end up. Everybody voting from Ontario will vote Carlo. Everybody else votes Suter.
Hossa said:Hey, only the GTA will vote Carlo, lol . I'm from Ontario (even though I don't currently reside there), and I vote Suter, although if we're talking all-round play, I can't see the justification for voting Carlo at all. Strictly offensively, its closer though.
Kryoptix said:Suter is better IMO but not by a big margin ..
im not talking about all round defensive game ...Reveille said:I think it's quite a large margin.
Suter is the better all around d-man and has a tad better offensive instincts. He's also younger.
Suter was one of the most underrated players in the 2003 draft around season beginning to 3/4 of the way through. Most didn't know WHERE he would be taken until near draft day.
Then the GMs got smart.
Toronto has KaberleSmokeyClause said:I would tend to say Suter but with Hamhuis on his team, PP point time won't be as readily available as it MIGHT be on Toronto in 6-10 years.
Suter has more offensive talent according to what I have read but I haven't seen Carlo. Though, methinks he might be a touch overrated by the Leafs HF editor.
Though, methinks he might be a touch overrated by the Leafs HF editor.
#37-#93-#27 said:Toronto has Kaberle
no guarantees with Hamhuis yet, Suter has better chance to plant himself as the #1 pp pointman then Carlo at this point
I would take Suter if given the choice
pinto80 said:not overrating him, hes our best prospect
Kryoptix said:suter is behind hamhuis in terms of offensive skills
SmokeyClause said:I think he is. He's an 8 according to whoever runs the leafs page. Suter is a 7.5 on the Preds page. Likely, the numbers should be swapped.
SmokeyClause said:Not really. Most of us don't hate the leafs. A vocal group does. But a vocal group hates the Habs and the Rag$ as well.
I think it's just an example of a better player going up against a Leaf. If you went Kevin Klein vs. Carlo, I'm sure the consensus would be Colaiacovo. I know my vote would be there as well.
Mike8 said:Mine wouldn't. And of course, I'd also take Suter any day over Colaiacovo. I'm not too high on Colaiacovo, though.