central scouting mid terms

Status
Not open for further replies.

Seachd

Registered User
Mar 16, 2002
24,938
8,947
Still anxiously waiting. Hopefully today, probably next week (just guessing).
 

bopeep

Registered User
Jan 22, 2004
1,736
2,325
bc
Seachd said:
Still anxiously waiting. Hopefully today, probably next week (just guessing).
I am patiently (well, somewhat) waiting as well. I'm thinking the list is compiled already as the Vancouver Sun reported at the beginning of the week that Gilbert Brule is the third ranked player for the 2005 draft (according to Central Scouting). Perhaps some post-WJC revisions :dunno:
 

Draftman

Registered User
Feb 28, 2002
1,111
34
Long Island, NY
Visit site
Here's the first round for NA skaters:

1. CROSBY, SIDNEY
2. POULIOT, BENOIT
3. RYAN, BOBBY
4. BOURDON, LUC
5. JOHNSON, JACK
6. BRULE, GILBERT
7. PARENT, RYAN
8. MCARDLE, KENNDAL
9. SKILLE, JACK
10. LASHOFF, MATT
11. STOA, RYAN
12. SETOGUCHI, DEVIN
13. MIKKELSON, BRENDAN
14. STAAL, MARC
15. DURAND, CHRIS
16. LEE, BRIAN
17. O'MARRA, RYAN
18. KINDL, JAKUB
19. BOURRET, ALEX
20. NEAL, JAMES
21. BLUNDEN, MICHAEL
22. JACKSON, SCOTT
23. COLLINS, DAN
24. DAVIS, PATRICK
25. SAUER, MICHAEL
26. LAWRENCE, CHRIS
27. ZAGRAPAN, MAREK
28. PAQUET, JEAN-PHILIPPE
29. ABDELKADER, JUSTIN
30. POKULOK, SASHA
 

trahans99

Registered User
Apr 7, 2004
1,443
0
Home of the 2005 Memorial Cup
Draftman said:
Here's the first round for NA skaters:

1. CROSBY, SIDNEY
2. POULIOT, BENOIT
3. RYAN, BOBBY
4. BOURDON, LUC
5. JOHNSON, JACK
6. BRULE, GILBERT
7. PARENT, RYAN
8. MCARDLE, KENNDAL
9. SKILLE, JACK
10. LASHOFF, MATT
11. STOA, RYAN
12. SETOGUCHI, DEVIN
13. MIKKELSON, BRENDAN
14. STAAL, MARC
15. DURAND, CHRIS
16. LEE, BRIAN
17. O'MARRA, RYAN
18. KINDL, JAKUB
19. BOURRET, ALEX
20. NEAL, JAMES
21. BLUNDEN, MICHAEL
22. JACKSON, SCOTT
23. COLLINS, DAN
24. DAVIS, PATRICK
25. SAUER, MICHAEL
26. LAWRENCE, CHRIS
27. ZAGRAPAN, MAREK
28. PAQUET, JEAN-PHILIPPE
29. ABDELKADER, JUSTIN
30. POKULOK, SASHA

wheres the link?
 

HabLover

Registered User
Mar 2, 2002
2,482
0
Sandspit
Visit site
Draftman said:
Here's the first round for NA skaters:

1. CROSBY, SIDNEY
2. POULIOT, BENOIT
3. RYAN, BOBBY
4. BOURDON, LUC
5. JOHNSON, JACK
6. BRULE, GILBERT
7. PARENT, RYAN
8. MCARDLE, KENNDAL
9. SKILLE, JACK
10. LASHOFF, MATT
11. STOA, RYAN
12. SETOGUCHI, DEVIN
13. MIKKELSON, BRENDAN
14. STAAL, MARC
15. DURAND, CHRIS
16. LEE, BRIAN
17. O'MARRA, RYAN
18. KINDL, JAKUB
19. BOURRET, ALEX
20. NEAL, JAMES
21. BLUNDEN, MICHAEL
22. JACKSON, SCOTT
23. COLLINS, DAN
24. DAVIS, PATRICK
25. SAUER, MICHAEL
26. LAWRENCE, CHRIS
27. ZAGRAPAN, MAREK
28. PAQUET, JEAN-PHILIPPE
29. ABDELKADER, JUSTIN
30. POKULOK, SASHA

Is this the 1st round for NA skaters or have you just thrown everyone together from each of the league rankings?

I like McArdle at #8, maybe a bit too high, but Bourdon over Jack Johnson seems a bit strange with all the hype surrounding Johnson.

Brule at #6 doesn't make sense, Durand at #15 seems a little low, as does Bourret at #19 and O'Marra has been a Top 10 pick by Redline and ISS to date, but is #17 by CSS.

....and where is Latendresse? He doesn't even make the 1st round? By these rankings he would be a mid to late 2nd rounder once you factor in all the Euro draft picks.
 

LaLaLaprise

lalalaprise -twitter
Feb 28, 2002
8,716
1
Halifax, Nova Scotia
Lets all hail CSB's worst rankings in a while LOL

It seems as though Redline, CSB and ISS are all trying to "out-do" each other in the "what the ****" category LOL
 

Hiishawk

Registered User
Feb 28, 2002
1,225
2
Out there somewhere
Visit site
It is always different from what other people say. So are NHL team lists. Now people will criticize it because it doesn't match what Redline or McKeen's says (which is where most people here build their rankings from). People will criticize it now, but when it becomes more established in their minds, or time passes and people accept it as a kind of standard, many people here will adjust their own lists closer to CSS's.

This is called the "Anikeenko" phenomenom (i.e., Nov.: "Anikeenko at #35? McKeen's is nuts!". Jan.: "I have Anikeenko at #35").
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad