Carson Soucy to have a hearing for Cross-check to Connor McDavid - suspended 1 game (MOD WARNING IN OP)

[Leonardo87]

MOD NOTE:

If you can't post in here without constantly trying to troll each other, you won't be posting in here. Consider this the one and only warning you'll get.

Click to read more...

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Nothing for the McBaby lumberjack swing? I guess he’s immune to punishment. Got away with a double minor in Game 2 as well.

Considering that BC's biggest industry is forestry I would have thought that people there would be better at identifying lumberjacks. It was a lovetap on the pants. Soucy gave him one back. Its the Vancouver D's two crosschecks afterward that are getting them in hot water.

 

[ManofSteel55]

View attachment 869915
Can we stop calling this a shin? Thanks

I agree. A slash at the lower legs would have been worse, there's way more of a chance to injure somebody by hacking at his lower legs than by giving him a tap on the hip.

 

[Bizzare]

What, his hockey pants?

Yes it’s not a shin, thanks for finally getting it right.

 

[LTIR]

Both are crap. Let’s be honest here. There’s a reason the Oilers started Skinner.

And there is a reason why Silov is playing ahead of the other goalie. He was the 2nd best nuck vs NSH and doing pretty good this series.. Demko isn't any better than what Silov gave

 

[BLNY]

The clip above is so disingenuous, leaves out the slashing beforehand.

This is the full clip:

https://x.com/CanucksArmy/status/1789875128672584167

Those whacks to the padding in the pant are really painful ...

 

[thegazelle]

Do whatever you want..just don't suspend Cole is what I ask.

Haha, so true. Cole is providing those expected intangible contributions from unexpected players, that become X-Factors in every playoffs...

 

[Bizzare]

are his pants going onto LTIR?

Is McDavids neck? Nope to both.

 

[NyQuil]

Very true, and that is a good comparsion.

Certainly many of us want to see some consistency here insofar as consequences, not just with this situation, but similar ones like it.

There’s a difference between cross checking a guy in the back of the head after he scores a goal, and accidentally cross checking a guy in the face after he slashes you with his stick and your teammate hits him from behind.

I expect less than what Rielly got.

 

[herzausstein]

A couple fines should be thrown around. Soucy was trying to go for the chest by the looks of it but Zadorov gets McDavid in the back which puts Soucy's crosscheck squarly to the neck/head region.

Probably couldve been a whole lotta nothing had Zadorov stayed out of it. Two players slashing/cross checking at the end of a heated game.

 

[geebster]

You just know Kane is going to give it right back to Hughes or Pettersson if there is no suspension. That also just opens the door for a complete shitshow next game so I'm leaning towards a suspension.

He was already slewfooting Hughes before this and trying to kick Zadorov in the face with his skate.

 

[LivingRentFree]

Can someone explain to me how the league reviewing this play makes McDavid soft? I don’t understand that one

I think it’s likely from the constant crying after every whistle.

 

[AvroArrow]

Yes, because I witnessed Bennet got away with a sucker bunch yesterday

Also Sedins got punched in the face repeatedly in front of refs 13 years ago

But we gotta protect McPrecious

Marchy was jabbing at the Sedins in a scrum mid game, which was normal 13 years ago, hardly the same thing. Hell that happens in playoff games even today.

Bennett should have got something for that as well, I been saying the same thing about him. It was a garbage play with intent to injure. But using your stick to hurt another player, especially after the game is over, cross check in the face ? Easy suspension.

 

[NyQuil]

Yes it’s not a shin, thanks for finally getting it right.

I never said it was his shin.

 

[Killer Orcas]

If Pickard or even Campbell playing it's 3-0 Oilers. Skinner is the only reason why this is a close series

Then I don't know maybe the coach is the problem you could pull Skinner earlier you realize. Campbell the guy that sucked so bad was sent to minors?

 

[The Expert]

Should have been a fine at most.

 

[Bizzare]

Well, if he was trying to just skate away, he probably could have done that. He's a big and strong guy. He chose to push him instead. He started it. McDavid escalated it, and then the Vancouver goofs went way beyond what the situation called for.

Being big and strong doesn’t do anything if he doesn’t push or make contact with McDavid…

 

[AvroArrow]

It's a weird one, because the result is bad but I don't think he was trying to cross check him in the face at all.

Zadorov cross checking him from behind put Soucy's cross check in a bad spot.

As per the league "A player has to be in control of his own stick at all times" teams are awarded powerplays for stick lifting the opponents stick into their own face. This is a guy cross checking someone, even if Zadorov doesn't hit McDavid it was still a pretty high cross check attempt.

 

[CantHaveTkachev]

Nah no excuses. They just don’t get a soft path to the conference finals like the Oilers do. That’s reality, not an excuse.

so the Leafs aren't good enough is what you're saying

kinda like when they had a path in 2021 by winning the Canadian division, or losing to CBJ

 

[WetcoastOrca]

Need to start. A

And there is a reason why Silov is playing ahead of the other goalie. He was the 2nd best nuck vs NSH and doing pretty good this series.. Demko isn't any better than what Silov gave

Demko is a Vezina finalist.
Skinner, Pickard and Campbell are not starter material.
Silovs was great in game 3 but put up below. average numbers in 1 and 2.
He’s been better than expectations as a third string rookie but he hasn’t been close to elite.

 

[LivingRentFree]

This guy should drink for free at any bar in Vancouver / Calgary / Toronto

​

I ordered his jersey last night

 

[Hodgy]

After the play is over? Swatting at each other with sticks?

Yes it happens frequently. Are you new to hockey?

I’m still waiting for all of your examples of retaliatory cross checks to the face going unpunished.

I think everyone agrees that the shot to the face was accidental, but it was still a penalty and the end result was contact to the face.

Lack of deliberate Intention might reduce the punishment.

He has Zadorov to thank for the phone call from the league.

Just a reminder that you said the type of slash happens dozens of times in a game. Again, that’s a ridiculous statement, and I assume you know that but for whatever reason are not willing to just concede your initial statement was a huge hyperbole and move on.

I don’t recall a big base ball swing slash after the game ending happening even once in any Canucks game this season. The idea that this happens frequently is a joke.

 

[LivingRentFree]

so the Leafs aren't good enough is what you're saying

kinda like when they had a path in 2021 by winning the Canadian division, or losing to CBJ

Definitely weren’t good enough nope!

Their best chance will be next year, or the year after when their cap space really opens up. Shanny will be gone then as well.

 

[CantHaveTkachev]

Is McDavids neck? Nope to both.

whack to the pants is exactly the same a cross check to the face

give me a break...glad the NHL is doing this

 

[IslandBeast]

The oilers strategy is literally just play draisaitl and McDavid half the game and hope that the other team takes lots of penalties and/or suspensions lol. What a recipe for success

 

[NyQuil]

Just a reminder that you said the type of slash happens dozens of times in a game. Again, that’s a ridiculous statement, and I assume you know that but for whatever reason are not willing to just concede your initial statement was a huge hyperbole and move on.

I don’t recall a big base ball swing slash after the game ending happening even once in any Canucks game this season. The idea that this happens frequently is a joke.

Big baseball swing. Lol.

Where’s the hyperbole now?

In another hundred posts you’ll be calling him Conan the Barbarian.

Soucy got slashed in the pants and Soucy slashed him back.

Then Zadorov hit him from behind and McDavid buckled, then Soucy cross checked him in the face.

The reason it won’t be more serious is because it was part of a scrum and it was pretty clear that Soucy’s intent was not to target the face.

It was the end result though which is why the league is looking at it.