08-09: .916/68 games - made playoffs
09-10: .916/47 games - injured, team missed by miles
10-11: .923/74 games - near miss
11-12: .915/68 games - Mo fired mid-season after slow start, team missed by 10 points
he had a rough start this year, but minus the first 2 games he's at .919, I expect his stats to normalize over the course of the season to somewhere close to that.
I consider .910 about average for a goalie so he's prettymuch been an above average goalie to me to varying extents since 07-08.
Not painting you into any category on this one, just a general statement on the boards overall. Cam's first two years after winning the cup were enough to really tarnish his reputation to a large part of fans around the league, and many of them are like Pauser who will argue with you until the end of the earth about it. The others are those that argue he's among the best in the game right now, and that his stats would be even better behind a competent defense. Of course, being that we haven't had one of those since 08-09 we have no way of knowing if that's accurate.
FWIW, the top 10 in that regard were Thomas, Vokoun, Lundqvist, Rinne, Luongo, Miller, Anderson, Ward, Hiller, Price, Quick (tie between the last 3). So I'd have Ward about 5th out of those that are actually active right now, just ahead of Price and Miller but not by much.