Only in our weird Penguins world are these two goalies BPA available. This is just the typical "smartest guys in the room bullshit" our scouts pull.
We are about to get skewered for these picks over the next couple years.
In 2013, the Pens got skewered for their picks. For years. Their top two picks were a backup from the Oil Kings, and a 5'9" forward!
You know. Jarry and Guentzel.
Allow me to quote Allan Muir of Sport Illustrated from his Draft Grade of the Pens (he gave them a C for that draft):
"Center Jake Guentzel (77) is dynamite on wheels, but he's just 5'-9" and probably will top out in the AHL"
Everywhere I could dig up gave the Pens a C or C- grade, and while they generally thought Jarry was a decent pick, most didn't even mention Guentzel, or had a similar review as Muir did.
You know what team was highly ranked for that draft by pretty much everyone? The Buffalo Sabres. With particular praise for their pick of Rasmus Ristolainen at 8th overall.
This happens every year. The whinging in these threads is identical to what we heard about the Guentzel and Goligoski picks.
Yep. People on these boards scoffed when the Pens said they felt that Guentzel would likely grow post-draft, since his father and brother had.
Explain to me the rationale behind drafting two goalies with Jarry already in your net, all the while being absolutely barren in the way of forwards and blueliners beyond Poulin and Legare (and I guess POJ, who is probably at best a bottom pairing, Ruhwedel-caliber guy right now).
It took Jarry 6 years from being drafted to playing in his first NHL game. That's not uncommon for goalies, who generally take the longest to develop. In 6 years, Jarry will be 32, while these guys will be 24.
Outside the very top of the first round, most prospects take years to reach the NHL, if they do at all. Even most first rounders take at least 2 years, if not more. We have no idea what the team will need in 2-6 years. Never draft based on what the NHL team needs. By the time they're ready, everything could be completely different. (Plus, we're talking about mid to late round picks here - chances are much higher that they'll bust then that they'll make it to the NHL. Even the highly touted ones).
I mean, the fact is that the chances are greatly against any of the players from the second round on ever making it to the NHL. Not just the Pens' picks, either. Without a first round pick, I'll consider the draft to have been successful if they can turn up even a single NHL regular out of it, in the end.