Proposal: Buffalo Proposals for Hanifin (Merged)

HaNotsri

Regstred User
Dec 29, 2013
8,112
5,969
Hanifin + Skinner + 1st

For

Kane + RoR
Take out their first, add Reinhart. They still would say no but at least we’d just get a frown rather than a slap.

We don’t have the firepower for both Skinner and Hanifin. ROR could get us one of those guys but for the other we’d have to pay woth our spare parts and I doubt that Hurricanes want them.

Best I can come up with:
ROR
Kane 50% retained
Reinhart
Lehner
Mccabe

For Hanifin, Skinner, Ward

Hurricanes can then swap Kane for a late second. Lehner and McCabe could turn their careers around but hold little value, Lehner has been good lately and behind a better defense he could be a legit starter.
Reinhart is... cheap. Obviously Hurricanes better believe that Reinhart is a potential stud to make this deal.
 
Last edited:

nickdawg95

scoutdawg
Jan 7, 2016
3,280
1,765
That's not remotely the question. This is lopsided in Buffalo's favor. ROR and a good rental =/= Hanifin, Skinner, and what's looking like a top-15 pick. Nope.

why? their top 6 would be vastly improved

Aho-O'Reilly-Teravainen
Kane-Staal-Williams
 

bobc222

Registered User
Mar 10, 2017
987
1,696
Hanifin + Skinner + 1st

For

Kane + RoR

A horror show of a deal for the Hurricanes.
Skinner is better than Evander Kane. Skinner's contract situation is better than Kane's.
O'Reilly is marginally better than Hanifin, when taking into account Hanifin's potential. Based on his upward trajectory and 1D potential, Hanifin will, in several years be equivalent in value to O'Reilly. Staal is already a player in a similar mold to O'Reilly, with better defense and less offesnive upside.
Under no circumstances is O'Reilly worth a future #1D, a 1st and the upgrade to Skinner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MinJaBen

Dr Quincy

Registered User
Jun 19, 2005
28,683
10,515
why? their top 6 would be vastly improved

Aho-O'Reilly-Teravainen
Kane-Staal-Williams

And then what will it look like next year when Kane walks?
And the year after when Williams retires?

Nevermind, that if O'Reilly and Kane are so great, how come BUFF has scored less pts than CAR with it's bad top 6?
 

Patagonia

Keep Whining
Jan 6, 2017
7,621
3,245
Remove Kane replace with Reinhart. Remove the 1st for 2nd.

ROR
Reinhart

for

Hanifin
2nd Round
 

Davin Craft

Registered User
Nov 7, 2017
62
3
ROR
Kane

For

Hanifin
2018 1st

ROR for Hanifin is fair
Kane for a 1st is fair

Canes get a great winger and first line center and the sabres get a top D prospect and good draft pick
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->