Puckhead
Registered User
Why do you think most NHL teams have been drafting the bigger goalies? Other than the obvious, to take up space.
exactly what i was going to sayPatrick - Flames Fan said:How about the fact that better athletes are usually bigger, stronger, faster? Look at the starst today in the NHL. Most of them are 6' or bigger. It is rare to find the top % full of small guys. Yes, there are a few but there are a lot mroe bigger forwards or defenseman than smaller elite ones. The same goes for goalies. Hockey has alot to do with size and power. It is just a direct relation.
Anthony said:exactly what i was going to say
everything is getting bigger and faster
its not just one particular position or anything
Puckhead said:Do you think that Schwarz being smaller than the others, could have had something to do with why he fell so far in the draft? If thats true, then whatever happened to taking the best player at that spot? It just stands to reason that if you want a big guy, then you choose a big guy. But not over a smaller guy who is a much better player. How many small players over the last decade have been overlooked, just because the league got in their collective heads that you have to be big to play this game and have success? Now with the likes of Sullivan and St. Louis among others, the little guy is standing up and saying let me show you what I can do. Is size all that matters in the NHL today?
Puckhead said:Do you think that Schwarz being smaller than the others, could have had something to do with why he fell so far in the draft? If thats true, then whatever happened to taking the best player at that spot? It just stands to reason that if you want a big guy, then you choose a big guy. But not over a smaller guy who is a much better player. How many small players over the last decade have been overlooked, just because the league got in their collective heads that you have to be big to play this game and have success? Now with the likes of Sullivan and St. Louis among others, the little guy is standing up and saying let me show you what I can do. Is size all that matters in the NHL today?
I frankly think the big goalie trend sucks considering most all the good goalies are around 6-1, not that thats considered small, but a team shouldnt take a 6-4 guy over a 6-0 guy just cause of size.Puckhead said:Why do you think most NHL teams have been drafting the bigger goalies? Other than the obvious, to take up space.
Flames Draft Watcher said:What do Sullivan and St. Louis have to do with small goaltenders? They are completely irrelevant to the discussion.
Size with goaltenders is a very different thing than with skaters because a smaller goalie leaves bigger holes to shoot at when he's in the butterfly. With a skater size can make a difference if they use their size to their advantage. With goaltenders size is an inherent advantage as they take up more of the net.
Obviously quickness, fundamentals, positioning, etc play a role. But if they are close then it's quite easy to see why scouts would lean towards the bigger guy. And as always projection is required. Schwarz may be quicker and better fundamentally than Dubnyk right now but they may be pretty close 5-6 years down the line after Dubnyk has received some excellent goalie coaching. If that's the case then he should be the better goalie because his size will give him the advantage.