Ben Bishop or Curtis Joseph

[Gilles Meloche]

Not talking longevity (Joseph played twice the games Bishop did). Identical save percentage in the post season, in a game 7 who do you want in goal?? Both seemed to be pretty clutch and too bad Bishops career got derailed from injuries.

Click to read more...

 

[Albatros]

Bishop is a big body with solid netminding basics, Cujo in his prime an elite goaltender. Not really the same tier at all.

 

[Tufted Titmouse]

CuJo. I still have childhood memories of him being electric for Edmonton in those playoff runs.

 

[banks]

There's a case to be made for Bishop.

I Just won't be the one to try and make that case. I voted CuJo!

 

[Connor McConnor]

Bishop is a big body with solid netminding basics, Cujo in his prime an elite goaltender. Not really the same tier at all.

While I agree with your overall take, a 3x top 3 Vezina finalist (and 2x top 10 Hart) can easily be considered an "elite goaltender" as well.

 

[Evergreen]

CuJo without a second thought.

 

[Gilles Meloche]

Quote from a post for “VinikToWinIt” on Bishop…

Below is a list of the last game of every series he has played in the playoffs throughout his entire NHL career.

7 games
Record: 6-1
Save percentage: 0.981 (!!!)
GAA: 0.571
Shutouts: 4

Tm		Opp	DEC	GA	SA	SV	SV%	SO
TBL		DET	W	0	31	31	1	1
TBL		MTL	W	1	19	18	0.947	0
TBL	@	NYR	W	0	22	22	1	1
TBL	@	CHI	L	2	32	30	0.938	0
TBL		DET	W	0	34	34	1	1
TBL		NYI	W	0	28	28	1	1
DAL		NSH	W	1	48	47	0.979	0

Thought it would be closer but I always thought Bishop was terribly underrated…

 

[HabzSauce]

I'm biased because I've seen a lot more of bishop in his prime than I have seen cujo.

I'm going with Big Ben. He was so hard to score against, I hated playing against him when he was in Tampa.

He played great with Dallas too

 

[Voight]

Quote from a post for “VinikToWinIt” on Bishop…

Below is a list of the last game of every series he has played in the playoffs throughout his entire NHL career.

7 games
Record: 6-1
Save percentage: 0.981 (!!!)
GAA: 0.571
Shutouts: 4

Tm		Opp	DEC	GA	SA	SV	SV%	SO
TBL		DET	W	0	31	31	1	1
TBL		MTL	W	1	19	18	0.947	0
TBL	@	NYR	W	0	22	22	1	1
TBL	@	CHI	L	2	32	30	0.938	0
TBL		DET	W	0	34	34	1	1
TBL		NYI	W	0	28	28	1	1
DAL		NSH	W	1	48	47	0.979	0

Thought it would be closer but I always thought Bishop was terribly underrated…

Yea, a lot of people forget he had a couple of Vezina worthy seasons. He'd have a much better rep if Tampa had won in 2015.

 

[BraveCanadian]

CuJo.. he was a lot better a playoff goalie than his reputation on the history board imo.

 

[Albatros]

Quote from a post for “VinikToWinIt” on Bishop…

Below is a list of the last game of every series he has played in the playoffs throughout his entire NHL career.

7 games
Record: 6-1
Save percentage: 0.981 (!!!)
GAA: 0.571
Shutouts: 4

Tm		Opp	DEC	GA	SA	SV	SV%	SO
TBL		DET	W	0	31	31	1	1
TBL		MTL	W	1	19	18	0.947	0
TBL	@	NYR	W	0	22	22	1	1
TBL	@	CHI	L	2	32	30	0.938	0
TBL		DET	W	0	34	34	1	1
TBL		NYI	W	0	28	28	1	1
DAL		NSH	W	1	48	47	0.979	0

Thought it would be closer but I always thought Bishop was terribly underrated…

How do Tampa's series clinching games look like after Bishop?

 

[Shane Diesel]

Bishop. Cujo is ridiculously overrated.