ATD2018 - Trade Thread

[BenchBrawl]

Please post your trades below, they are not processed until 4/5 GMs agree that it is allowed.

To make things easier on the trading committee (and the people updating the OP), please post both the round number and the exact pick numbers that you are trading, and please post your team names, not just GM names.

For full pick swaps just both parties need to post confirmation and it will be processed immediately

Please try to avoid On-The-Clock trading, it's rude to other GMs. But we understand in some cases it's necessary

Trade-Counter

BenchBrawl: 8
ImporterExporter: 6
rmartin65: 6
ResilientBeast: 4
TorontoTrades: 4
Sprague Cleghorn: 3
Velociraptor: 3
overpass: 2
jarek: 2
tinyzombies: 2
VanIslander: 2
JohnnyEngine: 2
Namba_17: 2
Stoneberg/markrander87: 2
Iceman: 2
Voight: 1
papershoes/HT18: 1
29Goalhoglung: 1
papershoes/Hawkey Town 18: 1
TheDevilMadeMe/Dreakmur: 1
Habsfan18: 1


Trades:

To jarek: 40th,88th,136th,184th
To BenchBrawl: 27th,118th,123th,214th

-

To Stoneberg & markrander87 - Halifax Citadels: 41 (2nd), 56 (3rd), 89 (4th), 185 (8th)
To Namba 17 - Portage Lakes Hockey Club 21 (1st) 76 (4th) 124 (6th), 165 (7th)

-

To Railers: 46, 51, 94
To Bankers: 24, 72, 121

Click to read more...

 

[Theokritos]

Please post your trades below, they are not processed until 4/5 GMs agree that it is allowed.

Technical question: With 24 entries, 4/5 GMs amounts to a fractional number. Are 19 or 20 yes votes going to be required?

 

[BenchBrawl]

I just copied/pasted from last year, 3 vet GMs is enough, and in some minor trades or standard trades cases 2 should do it.If the trade is controversial this is where we need more GMs like 4-5

 

[jarek]

Apparently we already have a trade. RB and I are swapping our entire pick sets. 22nd for 12th.

RB to confirm.

 

[ResilientBeast]

Uhmm I didn't confirm that

I put it out there but I'm still thinking

I like to see all the options

 

[jarek]

Uhmm I didn't confirm that

I put it out there but I'm still thinking

Oh ok, sorry about that.

Well, if you decide to confirm it, you've already got my approval.

 

[ResilientBeast]

Sounds good, the smaller draft size is throwing off all my quick maths

 

[GlitchMarner]

The fourth overall pick is on the table.

It will cost you, though.

 

[Iceman]

The 6th OA is available in a complete swap.

 

[BenchBrawl]

@Iceman check your pms

 

[Iceman]

Trade to announce:

Iceman and ResillientBeast - Complete swap of picks.


RB to confirm.

 

[ResilientBeast]

Trade to announce:

Iceman and ResillientBeast - Complete swap of picks.


RB to confirm.

Confirmed

 

[BenchBrawl]

lucky guy RB

 

[VanIslander]

never mind

 

[rmartin65]

The fourth overall pick is on the table.

It will cost you, though.

Check your PMs

 

[BenchBrawl]

Trade to announce:

To jarek - Kingsman Secret Agents: 40, 88, 136, 201

To BenchBrawl - Montreal Canadiens: 27, 118, 123, 214

 

[jarek]

Trade to announce:

To jarek - Kingsman Secret Agents: 40, 88, 136, 201

To BenchBrawl - Montreal Canadiens: 27, 118, 123, 214

Yep.

 

[BenchBrawl]

Need some GMs in here

 

[jarek]

Need some GMs in here

Seems like the trade is so obviously OK that nobody feels they need to speak up.

 

[Iceman]

I always thought that the person moving up first in a 4 piece trade should move up in the fourth pick and not third but we've seen plenty of these trades too so I guess it's fine, the pick difference is ok.... I guess?

 

[rmartin65]

I think one side comes out a bit ahead, but it is two experienced GMs, so... sure, I guess.

That said, I dont understand trades this early. If someone unexpectedly drops, the people who preemptively trade back are going to have some serious regret.

 

[BenchBrawl]

I think one side comes out a bit ahead, but it is two experienced GMs, so... sure, I guess.

That said, I dont understand trades this early. If someone unexpectedly drops, the people who preemptively trade back are going to have some serious regret.

No guts no glory

 

[rmartin65]

No guts no glory

Which is easier to say/live with as the person trading up.

 

[BenchBrawl]

Which is easier to say/live with as the person trading up.

OK, but in this specific case no one will drop to 27th that matters.I don't see any player where jarek would severely regret trading it.It's always the same players in this area.

Honestly, I feel like *I* might regret it if someone falls to 40th, and this is a more likely scenario based on past drafts.

 

[rmartin65]

OK, but in this specific case no one will drop to 27th that matters.I don't see any player where jarek would severely regret trading it.It's always the same players in this area.

Honestly, I feel like *I* might regret it if someone falls to 40th, and this is a more likely scenario based on past drafts.

It is quite possible that no one drops. Then again, someone might; that is why I said unexpectedly.

I mean, did anybody really see Howe going first this year? I am not saying it is a bad pick at all, but I strongly believe that it came out of left field for most people here.