Mr.Hunter74 said:
As for Meszaros I dont know a hole lot about him except that he has alot of skill and so far in the WHL has been quite the cheapshot artist. I think out of his 40pims i think 36 of them have been either and elbow, boarding, kneeing or hitting from behind. Yet out of all his rough and tough play he has only had 1 game in which he actually has a roughing which is actually a game misconduct plus a fight. Seems liek someone at the end of the game was able to get ahold of him and make him answer the bell for his antics. Personally i think this is just another one of those cases were a European player is going way way out of there way to show that they can play physical and not be intimidated by the North American game. Which is good but theres being phsycial and being kinda cheap. He wont be able to play like this when he hits pro or very much longer in the WHL i would think. Maybe thats the type of player he is though I am not sure. I like the fact he's willing to through the body around but I dont think he needs to play dirty to prove he can be physical. His scouting reports said he was more of a finnesse guy but could handle the rough play but i havent read one that said he was a cheap player at times. Hopefully this is just a prove to everyone i can handle the North American game kinda complex and his normal game will surface more often as he is very talented with some good size to boot.
I watch Meszaros every home game, and all the cheapshots you're talking about haven't happened. I can remember a couple boardings, one or two very unvicious elbows, no kneeings, and I don't remember any hitting from behinds. Unless he only ever does anything dirty on the road, he's definitely not a dirty player at all.
At least 15 of his PIMs came on one play where he fought and got a game minute misconduct, and unlike what you say, it was without a doubt he that initiated the fight. In fact, I would have said that play was the closest he's ever gotten to being dirty because he basically forced the guy to fight by just dropping his gloves and going at him.
You're right about the skill, and he has been very physical this year; in fact, if I have one complaint about him, it's that he occasionally takes himself out of position to hit. He's been an absolute wizard with the puck, his first pass is truly incredible (my favourite part of his game), he skates very well, his offensive instincts are very good, he eats up a ton of minutes, he's a rock in his own zone, and he's a physical force. So far from what I have seen in the WHL this year, Meszaros is the best defenseman in the western conference.
The bottom line is that he's a great CLEAN player.