[ANA] Gibson or [BOS] Subban?

[KlattNazty]

Which would you prefer?

Click to read more...

 

[Devilspuppet666]

gibson for me... i always liked him

 

[JMcLeaf]

Gibson

 

[7even]

Gibson. It's not a Leafs trade unless he turns into a 5 time all star

 

[HockeyGuruPitka]

Subban . Kid will be the steal of the 2012 draft.

Its absolutely unbelievable how good at hockey this kid is. Belleville is 18-9-3 this year, which is good for first place in their division. This is where the whacky part comes in. Malcolm’s brother Jordon (a 5'9 2013 draft eligible defenseman) is leading the team in scoring with 6g 16a and 22p in 31 GP. The team ranks DEAD LAST in goals for with 80. However the team is #1 in the league in goals against at 75. They are a mere +5 in the goals for department, however have managed to be a +9 in the wins department. This is in large part is thankful to a fantastic goaltender that performs unbelievably well under pressure..

 

[izzy]

Subban NO CONTEST. Kid will be the steal of the 2012 draft.

Its absolutely unbelievable how good at hockey this kid is. Belleville is 18-9-3 this year, which is good for first place in their division. This is where the whacky part comes in. Malcolm’s brother Jordon (a 5'9 2013 draft eligible defenseman) is leading the team in scoring with 6g 16a and 22p in 31 GP. The team ranks DEAD LAST in goals for with 80. However the team is #1 in the league in goals against at 75. They are a mere +5 in the goals for department, however have managed to be a +9 in the wins department. This is in large part is thankful to a fantastic goaltender that performs unbelievably well under pressure..

Wow, that is actually pretty impressive...

Gibson

 

[tsujimoto74]

I like Subban a lot, but I like Gibson more. Good poll, though.

 

[Rabid Ranger]

IMO Gibson has the edge in every area.

 

[Blind Gardien]

Can't go wrong with either one, but Subban is the best goalie I've seen coming through the OHL in a long time. He also seems to be on a nice progression slope as well.

 

[HockeyGuruPitka]

IMO Gibson has the edge in every area.

Lol impossible. Subban in two and a half years has never lost a shootout in the OHL.

 

[Future]

Can't go wrong with either one, but Subban is the best goalie I've seen coming through the OHL in a long time. He also seems to be on a nice progression slope as well.

That's odd because Gibson also plays in the OHL.

Gibson.

 

[Sojourn]

I'm going to say Gibson for purely selfish reasons, but I don't think you can go wrong with either.

 

[bruinsfan46]

Subban, better physical tools so more upside and he's at least as good in the OHL (he doesn't get to play behind Kitchener).

 

[3 Minute Minor]

I've never liked P.K but I think Malcolm is a top 3 goalie prospect at any age group outside of the NHL right now (Not including locked out NHLers) Such a natural, kind of have to be when you only start at 12 years old...

 

[BruinsBtn]

Just looked up Christopher Gibson...man, what happened?

 

[Hale The Villain]

Subban, better physical tools so more upside and he's at least as good in the OHL (he doesn't get to play behind Kitchener).

I wouldn't say Gibson is benefiting from Kitchener's system, I'd say it the other way around. He regularly keeps them in games.

The system in Kitchener only works because of him. Kind of like how the Rangers system is dependent upon Lundqvist.

 

[TheHudlinator]

I like both but I think Subban will be the better goalie, it's close tho.

 

[Exit Dose]

They're both great and goalie prospects are some of the most difficult to project, so I went with the homer vote.

 

[cneely]

Good poll.

Pretty much identical stats, and potential IMO. Both great prospects.

 

[HanSolo]

I'm gonna say Gibson, but Subban absolutely has the skill to change that.

 

[Leaf Rocket]

Gibson IMO so far.

 

[Rabid Ranger]

Subban, better physical tools so more upside and he's at least as good in the OHL (he doesn't get to play behind Kitchener).

I wouldn't say he has better physical tools. Gibson is bigger and more technically sound. I get Subban's "athleticism" but that's only one key to being a successful NHL goaltender.

 

[LeafOfBread]

Gibson. It's not a Leafs trade unless he turns into a 5 time all star

Lol wow, I didn't even know until you pointed that out. But yeah, if Gibson turns out great, it won't be long before irrational people start blame Burke for trading the pick.

 

[LeafOfBread]

Lol wow, I didn't even know until you pointed that out. But yeah, if Gibson turns out great, it won't be long before irrational people start blame Burke for trading the pick.

to blame*. And they're both really good, think I'll go with Subban though, really like what I've seen from him.

 

[HanSolo]

I wouldn't say he has better physical tools. Gibson is bigger and more technically sound. I get Subban's "athleticism" but that's only one key to being a successful NHL goaltender.

And with respect to Subban, Gibson is plenty athletic as well.