I was thinking the same thing,why do players have to have exact styles(and some guys demand they have to be the same size physically too!!)to discuss what player you would prefer?
I actually find comparisons of players who are very similar to be kind of boring really.If they are so similar,what's to nit-pick about?
Good point... sometimes it's just "if it was your turn to pick, who would you rather have"?
I think these comparisons go better when you have 2 unique players, as opposed to 2 future power forwards, or 2 small skilled centres.
As for who I'd pick? Bourret's history of weight problems bugs me... that's the kind of thing that could be destined to repeat itself. Some times bad habits creep back in, and it's hard to be an NHL'er if you are out of shape... I'd be leery of that.
As for Cogs, I don't think he'll be much of an NHL goal scorer, but he should be an effective player because he has great wheels and can do everything at full speed (which is the key, there have been lots of fast players who were busts, but not all of them could play the game at a high speed).
There will always be room in the NHL for a big guy who loves to through the body around, and there will always be room for the guys who can just play any role so in that regards, they will both get plenty of chances.
My homer pick goes to cogs though