That question can't be answered.
Points alone won't tell you that. Corey Perry just put up 53 points in 82 games, and even if you ignore the expectations that he's given us from previous seasons, I doubt you'll find many Anaheim fans who thought he played like a 1st line player.
Alternatively, a player could put up fewer points than that, and look every bit the part a top line forward.
Edit: And your poll options are completely at odds with the question you're asking. I'd almost wonder if you were intentionally trying to lead the poll to a response. A successful top line season for a player doesn't automatically mean they are a top scorer on a team.