GDT: 2018 Maple Leafs Trade Deadline Thread Pt.II

[Walshy7]

Why are people saying that's it?

Would people be ok with giving up a 1st, 2nd, Liljegren/Dermott (one of which NYR would have to have), Johnsson, and maybe another piece also ?

stop overvaluing what tampa gave up. none of those prospects tampa gave up come close to liljegren or dermott maybe johnsson even then johnsson is lighting up the AHL not a prospect who cant even reach ppg in the whl , demott is atop 4 NHL d not a top pair WHL dman.

 

[member 262271]

Nemestikov is a 25 year old center who is having a breakthrough year and is gonna put up 60-70 points this year.

Who would you compare him to on the Leafs?

To your point, nobody. Also though, he's not going to continue that point pace without Stamkos and Kucherov at his side. He's a good player but he was a benefactor of playing with those two, no question.

 

[Cor]

Outside of Ryan McDonagh, and Mike Green who didn't want to come here, there weren't really any other D available, other than Ian Cole.

 

[Legion34]

Meh. I think we could have beat the Tampa offer.

Brown, borgman, etc. 1,2.

People who are pissed that we didn’t trade jvr are nuts. Nash et al got a single late first a b prospect who we have a million of. Kane didn’t even get a 1st.

Tatar had term. It’s not at all the same

 

[Loosie]

Disappointed nothing was done today

Other quotes to this tweet implied Green's injury and his NMC were both factors.

 

[ShaneFalco]

Disappointed nothing was done today

nvm
wouldn't waive

 

[ShaneFalco]

Oh well, if they go out early it's not going to be pretty

 

[member 147413]

Look who he plays behind. Dude had 28 points last year. He’s feasting on easy matchups because of Kucherov, Stamkos, Point, Johnson and Palat. Miller is better than Namestnikov. Namestnikov will disappear next year. TB has made Yanni Gourde a f***ing 20 goal scorer.

 

[Daisy Jane]

yah green didn't want to come here.
(sigh)

 

[Cor]

Miller is likely worth the conditional 2nd + prospect by himself.

So Namestnikov, prospect + 1st for McDonagh.

Is that a fair breakdown?

Equivalent from us would like be Brown + Johnsson + 1st (Namestnikov better than Brown, but Johnsson better than Howden IMO)

 

[Loosie]

Dorion forgetting which Shore he traded.

 

[Mr Knies Guy]

Should have sold JVR and Komarov if you plan to roll with that D. Tatar got ridiculous price and Komarov is easily replaceable at this point

 

[pspot]

again i think the closest comparable is brown
so its brown and two 1st
then a mid prospect like bracco?

it would have been fun to see but i'm glad the leafs didn't do that

 

[ShaneFalco]

Hedman and McDonagh ouch

 

[Mr Knies Guy]

Yzerman absolutely schooled Gorton. Miller included was absolute genius.

 

[Scott Malkinson]

I think a comparable to that TB package for Ryan McDonagh would be:

Connor Brown
Andreas Johnsson
Andrew Nielsen
1st Round Pick
2nd Round Pick (conditional 1st)

 

[Loosie]

Tatar got a ridiculous price because Vegas had the picks they could surrender and not hurt them. Tatar was not getting that price anywhere else.

 

[Walshy7]

Miller is likely worth the conditional 2nd + prospect by himself.

So Namestnikov, prospect + 1st for McDonagh.

Is that a fair breakdown?

Equivalent from us would like be Brown + Johnsson + 1st (Namestnikov better than Brown, but Johnsson better than Howden IMO)

yes this is a very fair comparison, people overblowing tampas package pretending it includes a nylander or marner and a prospect at dermott or liljegrens level