2017 nhl redraft 1-15

[Castle8130]

Was curious to see how the 2017 draft is looking in the top 15 and who is looking like a bust. If you had to rank the top 15 right now. From the draft:
1. Hischier
2.Patrick
3.Heiskanen
4. Makar
5.Pettersson
6. Glass
7.Andersson
8. Mittelstadt
9.Rasmussen
10.Tippett
11. vilardi
12. Necas
13. Suzuki
14. Foote
15. Brannstrom


Mine:

1. Hischier
2. Pettersson
3. Heiskanen
4. Patrick
5. Mittelstadt
6. Tolvanen
7. Vesalainen
8. Glass
9. Necas
10. Makar
11. Rasmussen
12. Vilardi
13. Chytil
14. Jokiharju
15. Tippett
...
16. Andersson
I know these rankings might be weird, but I think this is where they are in terms of value as a player right now. There are a lot of other players that are in the convo too, like Thomas, Lind, yamamoto, Frost, Poehling, liljegren, Hague and Timmins that could make the top 15 swell

Click to read more...

 

[BoHorvat 53]

Was curious to see how the 2017 draft is looking in the top 15 and who is looking like a bust. If you had to rank the top 15 right now. From the draft:
1. Hischier
2.Patrick
3.Heiskanen
4. Makar
5.Pettersson
6. Glass
7.Andersson
8. Mittelstadt
9.Rasmussen
10.Tippett
11. vilardi
12. Necas
13. Suzuki
14. Foote
15. Brannstrom

1. Hischier
2. Pettersson
3. Heiskanen
4. Patrick
5. Tolvanen
6. Chytil
7. Makar
8. Mittlestadt
9. Vilardi
10. Andersson
11. Glass
12. Necas
13. Heponiemi
14. Liljegren
15. Foote

 

[ProspectsFanatic]

Vesalainen is in that draft too btw, just letting you know.

 

[Elias Pettersson]

Was curious to see how the 2017 draft is looking in the top 15 and who is looking like a bust. If you had to rank the top 15 right now. From the draft:
1. Hischier
2.Patrick
3.Heiskanen
4. Makar
5.Pettersson
6. Glass
7.Andersson
8. Mittelstadt
9.Rasmussen
10.Tippett
11. vilardi
12. Necas
13. Suzuki
14. Foote
15. Brannstrom


Mine:

1. Hischier
2. Pettersson
3. Heiskanen
4. Patrick
5. Mittelstadt
6. Tolvanen
7. Vesalainen
8. Glass
9. Necas
10. Makar
11. Rasmussen
12. Vilardi
13. Chytil
14. Jokiharju
15. Tippett
...
16. Andersson
I know these rankings might be weird, but I think this is where they are in terms of value as a player right now. There are a lot of other players that are in the convo too, like Thomas, Lind, yamamoto, Frost, Poehling, liljegren, Hague and Timmins that could make the top 15 swell

How do you have Mittelstadt above Tolvanen?

also no way Lind makes it to top 15. Even in my extremely biased opinion, he'd still barely make it into the last part of the first round. Frost I would also put barely outside of top 20 at this moment.

 

[Ainec]

hischier
chytil
heiskanen
pettersson
tolvanen
makar
patrick
mittelstadt
necas
vilardi
vesalainen

 

[Evilo]

Yamamoto has done everything you could hope for. Should be top 10.

 

[Kcb12345]

hischier
chytil
heiskanen
pettersson
tolvanen
makar
patrick
mittelstadt
necas
vilardi
vesalainen

You really think Chytil would go 2nd overall?

 

[Johno]

There's no one that has been amazing enough to jump Heiskanen. Pettersson has matched Heiskanen's awesome play but that does not put him over Miro.
They go 2-3 or 3-4, depending on how much one values what Patrick has been able to do in the NHL.

 

[howkie]

Im oki if people ignore Vesalainen, he is our secret. It both hurts but at the same time good he left Frölunda. Sometimes Rönnberg is such a bonehead.

 

[TheWhiskeyThief]

Im oki if people ignore Vesalainen, he is our secret. It both hurts but at the same time good he left Frölunda. Sometimes Rönnberg is such a bonehead.

I saw him early last season when he was playing with Lundqvist; did all the right things, but the puck never got on his stick. Ever. Joel had them playing 4vs5, not the coach.

 

[ConnorMcMullet]

How does Cale Makar fall to 10?

 

[BackWithaVengeance]

Remember the thread for awhile.

Nolan Patrick has shown nothing but improvement in every aspect of his game. Being healthy and having a full summer of conditioning will make him even better in 2018-19.

Also in before someone tells me Voracek is the reason why he has to be useful.

 

[Lays]

Nico
EP
Heiskanen
Tolvanen
Chytil
Makar
Mittelstadt
Nolan
Vilardi
Glass
Lias
Necas
Vesalainen

 

[Montecristo]

Too early for this list. Some types of players are under represented based on their skill set since people aren’t really watching. For example. Urho vaakananien played over 30 minutes for saipa of the top league in Finland in their final playoff game which led his team. He wasn’t really a point getter, but what he was in liiga was a #1 dman as an 18 year old. But he didn’t put up points so he won’t make any list. Maybe he’s not deserving, but I see carlo on a lot of 2015 top 15 redrafts and UV has a chance to be more dynamic

 

[Team Cozens]

Nico
Heiskanen
Mittelstadt
Pettersson
Patrick
Glass
Tolvanen
Makar
Chytil
Andersson
Vilardi
Vesalainen
Lilegren
Necas
Yamamoto

 

[Brando]

1. Hischier
2. Patrick
3. Heiskanen
4. Pettersson
5. Tolvanen
6. Mittlestadt
7. Makar
8. Necas
9. Chytil
10. Vilardi
11. Yamamoto
12. Glass
13. Andersson
14. Thomas
15. Veselainen

 

[Killerjas]

Was curious to see how the 2017 draft is looking in the top 15 and who is looking like a bust.

You are kidding right? It has only been 1 year since the draft.... No one is looking like a bust yet...

 

[Castle8130]

You are kidding right? It has only been 1 year since the draft.... No one is looking like a bust yet...

It's easier to tell every year, usually some players don't have a great d+1 season and a couple of those players eventually bust. It's just how the draft is shaping up rn. I'm sure it will look a lot different next year or at least a little different.

 

[Chuck Downie]

Not one list with Frost in the top 15?

 

[AmericanDream]

have to imagine Yamamoto moves up a few spots - kid has had a great year outside of a so-so WJC...

 

[MardyBum]

You are kidding right? It has only been 1 year since the draft.... No one is looking like a bust yet...

People were doing redrafts in like. . November haha.

 

[Hatter of the Beach]

I can already tell this thread is going to be full of people who made up their mind about Rasmussen a year ago and are either too lazy or too prideful to change it.

Dude is getting seriously underrated. He's had an excellent development season and is in the NHL next season.

 

[HoseEmDown]

If the same teams are picking then Tampa is still taking Foote. He's done nothing to be dropped from where he was picked. He hasn't made the case to move into the top 10 but hasn't done anything to be passed over either.

 

[My3Sons]

The real issue to me is that teams are excited about picks for a good part of the first round. This draft will likely play out better than it was given credit for.

 

[Elias Pettersson]

I can already tell this thread is going to be full of people who made up their mind about Rasmussen a year ago and are either too lazy or too prideful to change it.

Dude is getting seriously underrated. He's had an excellent development season and is in the NHL next season.

Hmm I've heard quite the opposite from wings fans. He has 4 more points in 3 less games. So no. Not a great development year. He was a bad pick at the time, especially with Vilardi available, and he's an even worse pick now. He would not be in top 20 in redraft