John Price
Bet
- Sep 19, 2008
- 372,060
- 23,933
Eli definitely can still be productive. He had a down year because he has no line, no WRs, and no running game.
I’m not sure what these people expected him to do with what he has right now?
I think Eli is done.
Eli is washed. Davis Webb stinks. Geno is a stop gap. Roll with Geno/Rosen next year.
I don’t know what’s **** McAdoo and Reese are doing by it’s not doing them favors.
I’m pissed off that this has happened.
Tons of Giants alumni have voiced their intense displeasure with how this was handled.
This season has been something to behold.
the Giants turned into the Jets in 3 short monthsTons of Giants alumni have voiced their intense displeasure with how this was handled.
This season has been something to behold.
Is Eli done? I mean, he's not winning or throwing for a ton, but he's also not turning the ball over (2:1 ratio), still completing balls at above his career accuracy, and has had no running game, defense, or receivers for most of the year. It just seems like an "everything that can go wrong has" sort of year in NY and Eli is taking the fall here.
This is really gross what has happened with the Giants here. They're supposed to be a class organization and this is not that, this is nonsenese you would expect from Oakland or Dallas. I hope McAdoo is fired at the end of the season.
But the raiders are a circus, that's the thing. There's always some controversy with them. The Giants are supposed to be the class of the league. The way this was done shows a marquee, super bowl winning organization in disarray, much like the Raiders were for years (and I guess a little bit still with how their season is going)Last time I checked the last legend the Raiders had was Charles Woodson and they did every single thing they could to get him a touchdown in his last home game. Including trying to have him throw a TD pass to Carr.
This is like if the Packers and Jets had forced Favre to stay on their rosters.